Model reputation as counterparty assurance gradient across four tiers

Add research on the journey from gamable opinion signals (reviews, ratings)
through observed metrics (PAYDEX, SLA stats), financial commitments (bonds,
escrow), and adjudicated outcomes (arbitration, courts). Resolve OpenQuestions:
no Reputation entity; use Reputation Signal, Performance Evidence, Commercial
Commitment, and Adjudication Outcome with Counterparty Assurance Gradient pattern.
This commit is contained in:
2026-06-21 22:57:28 +02:00
parent 0741a2e3a5
commit bd272151af
10 changed files with 383 additions and 11 deletions

View File

@@ -51,7 +51,16 @@ has incompatible meanings across source families.
| alei / ibrn | Registry Identifier (government_registry) | ISO 8000-116 | Authoritative legal entity identifier from government register. |
| iso 6523 / icd | Registry Identifier scheme | ISO/IEC 6523, PEPPOL | ICD + organization identifier encoding. |
| legal person | Legal Person | eIDAS, civil law, agency | Natural or juridical person under law. |
| paydex | Evidence Source | D&B | Credit/payment performance history. |
| paydex | Performance Evidence | D&B | Observed-tier payment performance metric. |
| reputation | Resolve by assurance tier | marketplaces, credit | Not canonical — see Counterparty Assurance Gradient. |
| star rating / review | Reputation Signal | Yelp, Amazon, App Store | Opinion-tier Evidence Source; weak, gamable. |
| feedback score | Reputation Signal | eBay, Uber | Platform-local opinion tier. |
| credit score | Performance Evidence | bureaus, D&B | Observed-tier counterparty metric. |
| performance bond / surety | Commercial Commitment | construction, procurement | Committed-tier financial assurance. |
| escrow | Commercial Commitment | marketplaces, Stripe | Committed-tier funds segregation. |
| arbitration award | Adjudication Outcome | AAA, ICC, JAMS | Adjudicated-tier dispute result. |
| court judgment | Adjudication Outcome | courts | Adjudicated-tier enforcement outcome. |
| assurance gradient | Counterparty Assurance Gradient | commercial identity | Four-tier reliance model (opinion → adjudicated). |
| kyc / cip | Evidence Source + Assurance | FinCEN, FATF | Regulated commercial identity onboarding. |
| crm account | Commercial Record | Salesforce | Company/household commercial record. |
| fluid identity | Persona / weak binding | theory | Low commercial stake; intentional mutability. |