Implements IHUB-WP-0009: closes four GAAF-2026 gaps before domain hub work begins. - TypeRegistry helper + controllers/views (hub_kind, hub_capability_manifest) - HubCapabilityManifest entity with validation and registry linkage - ARCHITECTURE-LAYERS.md + CI-enforced boundary contracts - Alembic migration 1743724800, fitness tests (Test/Architecture/) - GAAF spec, Operational Architecture spec, domain hub extension guide - Updates to CLAUDE.md, SCOPE.md, Schema.sql, Routes, FrontController, Types state_hub_sync: pending (tunnel was STALE at completion time; run fix-consistency) Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
7.4 KiB
IHF Functional Module Maturity Register
Framework: GAAF-2026 | Last reviewed: 2026-03-31 | Next review: 2026-09-30
This document is the authoritative maturity register for all IHF functional modules.
Maturity labels are defined in contracts/functional/module-maturity-labels.md.
Module Registry
| Module | Phase | Maturity | Stability Guarantee | Deprecation Policy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RequirementCandidate lifecycle | Phase 2 | Stable | Schema and controller API frozen | Major version only |
| DecisionRecord + governance ledger | Phase 3 | Stable | Schema and controller API frozen | Major version only |
| DeploymentRecord + OutcomeSignal | Phase 4 | Stable | Append-only invariant permanent | Major version only |
| AgentProposal + review workflow | Phase 5 | Beta | Core fields stable; confidence model may extend | Minor version notice |
| Cross-framework adapter contracts | Phase 6 | Stable | EnvelopeEmissionContract v1.0 immutable | Superseding contract version only |
| FrictionScore + BottleneckRecord | Phase 7 | Beta | Computation algorithm may improve | Minor version notice |
| HubHealthSnapshot | Phase 7 | Beta | Snapshot schema stable; score formula may change | Minor version notice |
| CrossHubPropagation | Phase 7 | Experimental | Pattern detection logic actively evolving | No notice required |
| WidgetOwnership + routing | Phase 8 | Stable | Ownership audit pattern permanent | Major version only |
| FederatedPolicyOverlay | Phase 8 | Beta | Activation immutability permanent; scope model may extend | Minor version notice |
| StewardshipRole | Phase 8 | Stable | Point-in-time audit pattern permanent | Major version only |
| ArchiveRecord + lineage inspector | Phase 8 | Beta | Soft-delete pattern stable; lineage query may deepen | Minor version notice |
| Type registries (widget, event, category, policy scope) | GAAF WP-0009 | Beta | Schema stable; seed vocabulary additive only | Additive additions only; no removal |
| HubCapabilityManifest | GAAF WP-0009 | Beta | Activation semantics stable; manifest protocol may version | Minor version notice |
Module Details
RequirementCandidate Lifecycle
Phase introduced: Phase 2
Tables: requirement_candidates
Stability: Stable — schema will not change within major version. Validation logic (status transitions: open → accepted/rejected) is frozen.
Known limitations: No formal state machine enforcement in the DB; status is TEXT constrained only at the controller layer.
Not guaranteed: The category field was previously validated against a hardcoded list; as of GAAF WP-0009 it is validated against annotation_category_registry. Applications querying directly may see new category values as the registry grows.
DecisionRecord + Governance Ledger
Phase introduced: Phase 3
Tables: decision_records
Stability: Stable — requirement_id, decided_by, decided_at, outcome, rationale are permanent.
Not guaranteed: The outcome_signals analysis may add new computed fields in GAAF analysis helpers.
DeploymentRecord + OutcomeSignal
Phase introduced: Phase 4
Tables: deployment_records, outcome_signals
Stability: Stable — outcome_signals is append-only (DB trigger enforced). Signal types are an extensible vocabulary.
Not guaranteed: Signal aggregation helpers may change computation logic.
AgentProposal + Review Workflow
Phase introduced: Phase 5
Tables: agent_proposals, agent_review_records
Stability: Beta — proposal_type, content, model_ref, status are stable. The confidence scoring model may be extended with additional fields.
Not guaranteed: Model reference format may evolve as new Claude models are released.
Cross-Framework Adapter Contracts
Phase introduced: Phase 6
Tables: envelope_emission_contracts, interaction_reporting_contracts, widget_adapter_specs
Stability: Stable — EnvelopeEmissionContract v1.0 is immutable. New versions are additive and published as new rows.
Not guaranteed: The maturity column was added in GAAF WP-0009; existing tooling may not surface this badge.
FrictionScore + BottleneckRecord
Phase introduced: Phase 7
Tables: friction_scores, bottleneck_records
Stability: Beta — schema is stable. The score computation algorithm in Application.Helper.FrictionScore may be tuned without notice.
Not guaranteed: Absolute score values are not stable across algorithm versions; use comparisons within a single version window.
HubHealthSnapshot
Phase introduced: Phase 7
Tables: hub_health_snapshots
Stability: Beta — snapshot schema stable. The composite health score formula may change in Phase 9+ as new signals are added.
Not guaranteed: Historical snapshots retain the score at computation time; they will not be recalculated retroactively.
CrossHubPropagation
Phase introduced: Phase 7
Tables: cross_hub_propagations
Stability: Experimental — pattern detection logic is actively being refined. Schema fields may be renamed or retyped.
Not guaranteed: Detection heuristics, pattern names, and score thresholds will change without notice.
WidgetOwnership + Routing
Phase introduced: Phase 8
Tables: widget_ownerships, hub_routing_rules
Stability: Stable — ownership audit pattern (point-in-time owned_since/owned_until) is permanent. Routing rule schema is stable.
Not guaranteed: As of GAAF WP-0009, match_category and match_widget_type are now validated against type registries; routing rules using unregistered type names will fail validation.
FederatedPolicyOverlay
Phase introduced: Phase 8
Tables: federated_policy_overlays
Stability: Beta — activation immutability is permanent (activated overlays cannot be edited). The scope model (source/target hub relationships) may extend.
Not guaranteed: Policy overlay conflict detection heuristics may change.
StewardshipRole
Phase introduced: Phase 8
Tables: stewardship_roles
Stability: Stable — the point-in-time role audit pattern is permanent. Role type vocabulary is additive.
ArchiveRecord + Lineage Inspector
Phase introduced: Phase 8
Tables: archive_records
Stability: Beta — soft-delete pattern is stable. Lineage query depth and the lineage JSONB structure may be extended.
Not guaranteed: Deep lineage graph queries may become paginated in Phase 9+.
Type Registries
Phase introduced: GAAF WP-0009
Tables: widget_type_registry, event_type_registry, annotation_category_registry, policy_scope_registry
Stability: Beta — schema stable. Framework seed vocabulary is permanent (names cannot be removed, only deprecated). Domain hub vocabulary grows as manifests are activated.
Not guaranteed: Registry UI and bulk import APIs are planned for Phase 10 and will extend the controller surface.
HubCapabilityManifest
Phase introduced: GAAF WP-0009
Tables: hub_capability_manifests
Stability: Beta — activation semantics (draft → active → retired, type auto-registration on activation, read-only after activation) are permanent.
Not guaranteed: The manifest protocol version (manifest_version field) will be bumped if the activation semantics change. Amendment workflow (currently manual retire + new draft) may be replaced by a DraftAmendmentAction in Phase 10.