# Cost Tracking Implementation Issues

**Generated**: 2025-10-04
**Source**: Issue #88 - Cost Tracking for Issues
**Target**: Comprehensive financial management system for MarkiTect

This document contains 9 specific implementation issues to build the cost tracking system described in issue #88.

## Priority Matrix

| Priority | Issue Count | Description |
|----------|-------------|-------------|
| **High** | 3 issues | Core infrastructure and database foundation |
| **Medium** | 4 issues | Business logic and integration |
| **Low** | 2 issues | Reporting and advanced features |

## Dependency Chain

```
Foundation Layer:
├── Issue 1: Database Schema ← (no dependencies)
├── Issue 2: Cost Item Management ← depends on Issue 1
└── Issue 3: Period Management ← depends on Issue 1

Business Logic Layer:
├── Issue 4: Issue Activity Tracking ← depends on Issue 1
├── Issue 5: Cost Allocation Engine ← depends on Issues 1, 2, 3, 4
└── Issue 6: Issue Management Integration ← depends on Issues 4, 5

User Interface Layer:
├── Issue 7: Financial Reporting ← depends on Issues 1, 2, 3, 5
├── Issue 8: CLI Commands ← depends on all previous issues
└── Issue 9: Automation & Scheduling ← depends on all previous issues
```

---

## Issue 1: Implement Cost Tracking Database Schema

**Priority**: HIGH | **Effort**: 2 days | **Dependencies**: None

### User Story
As a system administrator, I want a robust database schema for financial data so that all cost tracking information is properly structured and maintains data integrity.

### Description
Create the foundational database schema for the cost tracking system, including tables for cost items, periods, transactions, and allocations with proper relationships and constraints.

### Technical Implementation
- **New Files**:
  - `markitect/finance/__init__.py`
  - `markitect/finance/models.py`
  - `markitect/finance/migrations/001_create_cost_tables.sql`
  - `tests/test_finance_models.py`
- **Modified Files**:
  - Database schema files
  - Migration system

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Complete database schema with all required tables
- [ ] Proper foreign key relationships and constraints
- [ ] Database migration scripts for schema creation
- [ ] SQLAlchemy models with validation
- [ ] Decimal precision for financial calculations
- [ ] Audit trail capabilities (created_at, updated_at)
- [ ] Database indexes for performance
- [ ] Unit tests for model relationships and validation

### Related Issues
Foundation for Issue #88 (Cost Tracking for Issues)

---

## Issue 2: Implement Cost Item Management System

**Priority**: HIGH | **Effort**: 3 days | **Dependencies**: Issue 1

### User Story
As a project manager, I want to register and manage cost items (monthly subscriptions, one-time expenses) so that I can track all project-related expenses systematically.

### Description
Build the cost item management system that handles registration, lifecycle management, and categorization of both recurring and one-time costs.

### Technical Implementation
- **New Files**:
  - `markitect/finance/cost_manager.py`
  - `markitect/finance/cost_categories.py`
  - `tests/test_cost_manager.py`
- **Modified Files**: None

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] CostManager class with CRUD operations
- [ ] Support for monthly and one-time cost types
- [ ] Cost categorization system
- [ ] Cost item lifecycle management (active/inactive)
- [ ] Date-based cost validity periods
- [ ] Cost amount validation and currency handling
- [ ] Category-based cost organization
- [ ] Comprehensive test coverage for all operations

### Related Issues
Core component for Issue #88 (Cost Tracking for Issues)

---

## Issue 3: Implement Period Management Framework

**Priority**: HIGH | **Effort**: 2 days | **Dependencies**: Issue 1

### User Story
As a financial administrator, I want to manage calculation periods so that costs can be properly allocated and tracked within specific timeframes.

### Description
Create the period management system that handles period creation, status management, and period-based calculations for cost allocation.

### Technical Implementation
- **New Files**:
  - `markitect/finance/period_manager.py`
  - `tests/test_period_manager.py`
- **Modified Files**: None

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] PeriodManager class with period lifecycle management
- [ ] Period status management (open/calculating/closed)
- [ ] Automatic period creation and transitions
- [ ] Period overlap validation
- [ ] Period-based data aggregation
- [ ] Loss carried forward calculations
- [ ] Period closure validation
- [ ] Unit tests for all period operations

### Related Issues
Core component for Issue #88 (Cost Tracking for Issues)

---

## Issue 4: Implement Issue Activity Tracking

**Priority**: MEDIUM | **Effort**: 2 days | **Dependencies**: Issue 1

### User Story
As a system, I want to automatically track issue activities so that I can identify which issues are active during each cost allocation period.

### Description
Build an activity tracking system that monitors issue creation, modification, and other activities to determine which issues should receive cost allocations.

### Technical Implementation
- **New Files**:
  - `markitect/finance/activity_tracker.py`
  - `tests/test_activity_tracker.py`
- **Modified Files**:
  - Existing issue management hooks

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] ActivityTracker class with event capture
- [ ] Integration with existing issue management system
- [ ] Activity type classification (created, modified, commented)
- [ ] Period-based activity queries
- [ ] Historical activity data migration
- [ ] Activity deduplication logic
- [ ] Performance optimization for large datasets
- [ ] Tests with mock issue activities

### Related Issues
Data source for Issue #88 (Cost Tracking for Issues)

---

## Issue 5: Implement Cost Allocation Engine

**Priority**: MEDIUM | **Effort**: 4 days | **Dependencies**: Issues 1, 2, 3, 4

### User Story
As a financial system, I want to automatically allocate costs to active issues so that each issue reflects its fair share of operational expenses.

### Description
Create the core allocation engine that distributes costs across active issues using the defined algorithm, handles edge cases, and maintains audit trails.

### Technical Implementation
- **New Files**:
  - `markitect/finance/allocation_engine.py`
  - `markitect/finance/transaction_manager.py`
  - `tests/test_allocation_engine.py`
- **Modified Files**: None

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] AllocationEngine class with cost distribution logic
- [ ] Equal distribution algorithm implementation
- [ ] Loss carried forward handling
- [ ] Transaction audit trail creation
- [ ] Edge case handling (no active issues, partial periods)
- [ ] Allocation reversal capabilities
- [ ] Performance optimization for large allocations
- [ ] Comprehensive tests for all allocation scenarios

### Related Issues
Core functionality for Issue #88 (Cost Tracking for Issues)

---

## Issue 6: Integrate with Issue Management System

**Priority**: MEDIUM | **Effort**: 2 days | **Dependencies**: Issues 4, 5

### User Story
As a user, I want cost tracking to work seamlessly with the existing issue management system so that cost allocations happen automatically without manual intervention.

### Description
Integrate the cost tracking system with MarkiTect's existing issue management, adding hooks for automatic activity tracking and cost allocation triggers.

### Technical Implementation
- **New Files**:
  - `markitect/finance/issue_integration.py`
  - `tests/test_issue_integration.py`
- **Modified Files**:
  - Existing issue management modules
  - Issue lifecycle hooks

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Automatic activity tracking on issue events
- [ ] Integration with existing issue CRUD operations
- [ ] Cost allocation triggers for period closure
- [ ] Issue valuation updates
- [ ] Backward compatibility with existing functionality
- [ ] Performance impact assessment
- [ ] Error handling for integration failures
- [ ] Integration tests with real issue data

### Related Issues
Integration component for Issue #88 (Cost Tracking for Issues)

---

## Issue 7: Implement Financial Reporting System

**Priority**: MEDIUM | **Effort**: 3 days | **Dependencies**: Issues 1, 2, 3, 5

### User Story
As a project manager, I want comprehensive financial reports so that I can understand cost trends, issue valuations, and budget performance.

### Description
Build a reporting system that generates cost summaries, trend analysis, issue-specific cost breakdowns, and export capabilities for external analysis.

### Technical Implementation
- **New Files**:
  - `markitect/finance/reports.py`
  - `markitect/finance/report_generators.py`
  - `tests/test_financial_reports.py`
- **Modified Files**: None

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] FinancialReports class with multiple report types
- [ ] Cost summary reports by period
- [ ] Issue-specific cost analysis
- [ ] Cost trend analysis over time
- [ ] Budget variance reporting
- [ ] Export capabilities (CSV, JSON, PDF)
- [ ] Report caching for performance
- [ ] Tests for report accuracy and formatting

### Related Issues
Reporting component for Issue #88 (Cost Tracking for Issues)

---

## Issue 8: Implement Cost Tracking CLI Commands

**Priority**: LOW | **Effort**: 3 days | **Dependencies**: All previous issues

### User Story
As a user, I want intuitive CLI commands for cost management so that I can easily register costs, manage periods, and generate reports from the command line.

### Description
Create comprehensive CLI commands that provide access to all cost tracking functionality through the existing MarkiTect CLI framework.

### Technical Implementation
- **New Files**:
  - `markitect/finance/cli_commands.py`
  - `tests/test_finance_cli.py`
- **Modified Files**:
  - `markitect/cli.py`

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Cost management commands (add, list, update, remove)
- [ ] Period management commands (create, calculate, close, list)
- [ ] Report generation commands
- [ ] Data export commands
- [ ] Proper error handling and user feedback
- [ ] Integration with existing CLI framework
- [ ] CLI help documentation and examples
- [ ] Command-line argument validation

### Related Issues
User interface for Issue #88 (Cost Tracking for Issues)

---

## Issue 9: Implement Automation and Scheduling

**Priority**: LOW | **Effort**: 2 days | **Dependencies**: All previous issues

### User Story
As a system administrator, I want automated cost calculations and period management so that the financial tracking system requires minimal manual intervention.

### Description
Add automation capabilities for period creation, cost calculations, and alerting to make the cost tracking system largely self-managing.

### Technical Implementation
- **New Files**:
  - `markitect/finance/automation.py`
  - `markitect/finance/scheduler.py`
  - `tests/test_finance_automation.py`
- **Modified Files**: None

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Automatic period creation at month boundaries
- [ ] Scheduled cost allocation calculations
- [ ] Alert system for budget overruns
- [ ] Automated report generation
- [ ] Integration with system cron/scheduling
- [ ] Error notification system
- [ ] Configurable automation settings
- [ ] Tests for all automated processes

### Related Issues
Automation component for Issue #88 (Cost Tracking for Issues)

---

## Implementation Timeline

### **Phase 1: Foundation (Week 1)**
- **Days 1-2**: Issue 1 (Database Schema)
- **Days 3-5**: Issue 2 (Cost Item Management)
- **Days 6-7**: Issue 3 (Period Management)

### **Phase 2: Business Logic (Week 2-3)**
- **Days 8-9**: Issue 4 (Activity Tracking)
- **Days 10-13**: Issue 5 (Allocation Engine)
- **Days 14-15**: Issue 6 (Issue Integration)

### **Phase 3: User Features (Week 3-4)**
- **Days 16-18**: Issue 7 (Financial Reporting)
- **Days 19-21**: Issue 8 (CLI Commands)
- **Days 22-23**: Issue 9 (Automation)

**Total Estimated Effort**: 23 development days (4.5 weeks)

## Success Metrics

### **Functional Requirements**
- ✅ Accurate financial calculations with audit trail
- ✅ Seamless integration with existing issue management
- ✅ Comprehensive reporting and analysis capabilities
- ✅ Automated operations with minimal manual intervention

### **Performance Requirements**
- Monthly calculations complete in <5 seconds
- Support for 1000+ cost items and 10,000+ issues
- Report generation in <10 seconds
- Database queries optimized for financial data

### **Quality Requirements**
- >95% test coverage for financial calculations
- Zero tolerance for financial data corruption
- Comprehensive audit trail for all transactions
- Professional-grade financial reporting

This implementation plan provides a complete cost tracking and allocation system that will give MarkiTect sophisticated financial management capabilities for project cost analysis and resource allocation decisions.