---
entity_slug: madeira_wine_trade_exception
evaluator: null
evaluated_at: '2026-02-23T05:41:46.449736'
overall_score: 4.2
scores:
- name: definition_precision
  value: 4.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: The definition clearly identifies a specific trade arrangement with precise
    parameters - Madeira wine's exemption from restrictions that applied to European
    wines due to differential duty structures. The concept is distinct and well-bounded,
    though it could be slightly more precise about the exact nature of the "heavy
    duties" mechanism.
- name: source_grounding
  value: 5.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: This entity appears to be directly grounded in Smith's actual discussion
    of colonial trade policies and wine import regulations in Book IV, Chapter 4.
    The specific details about duty drawbacks and the resulting market preferences
    align with Smith's analytical approach to trade policy consequences.
- name: domain_placement
  value: 5.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: The "Exchange" domain is perfectly appropriate as this entity concerns
    international trade arrangements, import/export regulations, and market access
    policies. This is fundamentally about the mechanics of commercial exchange between
    regions.
- name: vsm_relevance
  value: 3.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: This maps reasonably well to S4 (intelligence/environmental adaptation)
    as it represents how trade systems adapt to regulatory environments and create
    market intelligence about preferences. However, it's somewhat specific to be a
    strong VSM exemplar and doesn't clearly illuminate broader systemic coordination
    principles.
- name: explanatory_value
  value: 4.0
  max_value: 5.0
  rationale: This entity effectively illuminates how trade policy exceptions can create
    unintended market consequences and preference formation - a genuine economic mechanism.
    It demonstrates Smith's insight into how regulatory asymmetries shape commercial
    patterns, though it's somewhat narrow in scope.
---

# Evaluation: Madeira Wine Trade Exception

## definition_precision — 4.0 / 5.0

The definition clearly identifies a specific trade arrangement with precise parameters - Madeira wine's exemption from restrictions that applied to European wines due to differential duty structures. The concept is distinct and well-bounded, though it could be slightly more precise about the exact nature of the "heavy duties" mechanism.

## source_grounding — 5.0 / 5.0

This entity appears to be directly grounded in Smith's actual discussion of colonial trade policies and wine import regulations in Book IV, Chapter 4. The specific details about duty drawbacks and the resulting market preferences align with Smith's analytical approach to trade policy consequences.

## domain_placement — 5.0 / 5.0

The "Exchange" domain is perfectly appropriate as this entity concerns international trade arrangements, import/export regulations, and market access policies. This is fundamentally about the mechanics of commercial exchange between regions.

## vsm_relevance — 3.0 / 5.0

This maps reasonably well to S4 (intelligence/environmental adaptation) as it represents how trade systems adapt to regulatory environments and create market intelligence about preferences. However, it's somewhat specific to be a strong VSM exemplar and doesn't clearly illuminate broader systemic coordination principles.

## explanatory_value — 4.0 / 5.0

This entity effectively illuminates how trade policy exceptions can create unintended market consequences and preference formation - a genuine economic mechanism. It demonstrates Smith's insight into how regulatory asymmetries shape commercial patterns, though it's somewhat narrow in scope.
