#!/usr/bin/env python3 """ Issue #59 Prevention Demonstration This example shows how the Requirements Engineering Agent would have prevented the interface compatibility issues and mock object mismatches encountered during Issue #59 development. """ import sys from pathlib import Path from unittest.mock import Mock from datetime import datetime, timezone # Add project root to path for imports project_root = Path(__file__).parent.parent sys.path.insert(0, str(project_root)) from domain.issues.models import Issue, IssueState, Label from tools.requirements_engineering_toolkit import RequirementsEngineeringAgent def demonstrate_issue_59_problems(): """Demonstrate the actual problems encountered in Issue #59.""" print("๐Ÿšจ DEMONSTRATING ISSUE #59 PROBLEMS") print("=" * 50) print("\nโŒ PROBLEM 1: Mock object didn't match domain model") print("-" * 50) # This is what was done in the original tests (WRONG) mock_issue_wrong = Mock() mock_issue_wrong.number = 59 mock_issue_wrong.title = "Test Issue" mock_issue_wrong.state = "open" # โŒ String instead of enum! mock_issue_wrong.labels = [] print(f"Mock state type: {type(mock_issue_wrong.state)} (should be IssueState enum)") print(f"Mock state value: {mock_issue_wrong.state}") # The real domain model uses enums real_issue = Issue( number=59, title="Test Issue", state=IssueState.OPEN, # โœ… Actual enum labels=[], created_at=datetime.now(timezone.utc), updated_at=datetime.now(timezone.utc) ) print(f"Real state type: {type(real_issue.state)}") print(f"Real state value: {real_issue.state}") print("\nโŒ PROBLEM 2: Missing required attributes") print("-" * 50) # Original mock was missing critical attributes print("Mock attributes:", [attr for attr in dir(mock_issue_wrong) if not attr.startswith('_')]) print("Real attributes:", [attr for attr in dir(real_issue) if not attr.startswith('_')]) missing_attrs = set(dir(real_issue)) - set(dir(mock_issue_wrong)) print(f"Missing attributes in mock: {[attr for attr in missing_attrs if not attr.startswith('_')]}") def demonstrate_requirements_engineering_solution(): """Demonstrate how the Requirements Engineering Agent would prevent these problems.""" print("\n\nโœ… REQUIREMENTS ENGINEERING AGENT SOLUTION") print("=" * 50) agent = RequirementsEngineeringAgent(project_root) print("\n๐Ÿ” STEP 1: Foundation Analysis") print("-" * 30) # Analyze existing domain models first foundation_analysis = agent.analyze_project_foundations() print(f"Found {foundation_analysis['foundation_analysis']['summary']['total_domain_models']} domain models") # Show Issue model details if 'Issue' in foundation_analysis['foundation_analysis']['domain_models']: issue_model = foundation_analysis['foundation_analysis']['domain_models']['Issue'] print(f"Issue model attributes: {list(issue_model.attributes.keys())}") print(f"Issue model methods: {issue_model.methods}") print("\n๐Ÿ“‹ STEP 2: Generate Development Checklist") print("-" * 30) checklist = agent.generate_development_checklist("Issue Management CLI", { "requires_issue_model": True, "creates_new_interface": True }) for phase in checklist: print(f"\n{phase['phase']}:") for task in phase['tasks']: print(f" โ€ข {task}") print("\n๐Ÿงช STEP 3: Correct Mock Creation") print("-" * 30) # This is how mocks should be created with the agent's guidance mock_issue_correct = Mock(spec=Issue) # โœ… Use spec= parameter mock_issue_correct.number = 59 mock_issue_correct.title = "Test Issue" mock_issue_correct.state = IssueState.OPEN # โœ… Use actual enum mock_issue_correct.labels = [] mock_issue_correct.created_at = datetime.now(timezone.utc) # โœ… Include all required attributes mock_issue_correct.updated_at = datetime.now(timezone.utc) print("โœ… Correctly created mock with spec=Issue") print(f"โœ… State is proper enum: {type(mock_issue_correct.state)}") print(f"โœ… All required attributes included") # Validate the mock validation_result = agent.mock_validator.validate_mock_against_model(mock_issue_correct, "Issue") if validation_result.is_valid: print("โœ… Mock validation passed!") else: print(f"โŒ Mock validation failed: {validation_result.errors}") def demonstrate_interface_compatibility_checking(): """Demonstrate interface compatibility checking.""" print("\n\n๐Ÿ”Œ INTERFACE COMPATIBILITY DEMONSTRATION") print("=" * 50) agent = RequirementsEngineeringAgent(project_root) print("\n๐Ÿ“Š Interface Analysis") print("-" * 20) # This would check if new plugin interface is compatible with existing repository # In the actual Issue #59, this would have caught the mismatch between # what the tests expected and what the actual GiteaIssueRepository provided print("โœ… Would verify that IssueBackend interface matches GiteaIssueRepository methods") print("โœ… Would catch async/sync mismatch (repository is async, plugin interface is sync)") print("โœ… Would identify missing adapter layer needed") # Example compatibility check result compatibility_result = { "compatible": False, "issues": [ "GiteaIssueRepository.get_issues() is async, but IssueBackend.list_issues() is sync", "Parameter mismatch: repository uses issue_number (int), interface uses issue_id (str)", "Repository returns additional attributes not defined in interface" ], "recommendations": [ "Add async adapter layer", "Standardize parameter types", "Extend interface to include all repository attributes" ] } print("\nCompatibility check would have found:") for issue in compatibility_result["issues"]: print(f" โŒ {issue}") print("\nRecommendations:") for rec in compatibility_result["recommendations"]: print(f" ๐Ÿ’ก {rec}") def demonstrate_correct_development_workflow(): """Demonstrate the correct development workflow using the agent.""" print("\n\n๐ŸŽฏ CORRECT DEVELOPMENT WORKFLOW") print("=" * 50) print("\n๐Ÿ“‹ Phase 1: Foundation Analysis") print("-" * 30) print("โœ… Analyze existing Issue domain model") print("โœ… Map GiteaIssueRepository interface") print("โœ… Understand async/sync requirements") print("โœ… Document existing infrastructure patterns") print("\n๐Ÿ“‹ Phase 2: Interface Contract Definition") print("-" * 30) print("โœ… Define IssueBackend abstract base class") print("โœ… Plan async adapter pattern") print("โœ… Ensure compatibility with existing infrastructure") print("โœ… Document interface contracts") print("\n๐Ÿ“‹ Phase 3: Test Architecture Design") print("-" * 30) print("โœ… Create mocks with Mock(spec=Issue)") print("โœ… Use actual enums and types") print("โœ… Include all required attributes") print("โœ… Plan integration test strategy") print("\n๐Ÿ“‹ Phase 4: Implementation") print("-" * 30) print("โœ… Implement IssueBackend base class") print("โœ… Create GiteaPlugin with async adapter") print("โœ… Add CLI commands using plugin manager") print("โœ… Maintain backward compatibility") print("\n๐Ÿ“‹ Phase 5: Validation") print("-" * 30) print("โœ… Validate all mocks match real objects") print("โœ… Test interface compatibility") print("โœ… Run integration tests") print("โœ… Verify end-to-end workflows") def create_agent_usage_example(): """Show actual agent usage commands.""" print("\n\n๐Ÿ› ๏ธ AGENT USAGE COMMANDS") print("=" * 50) print("\n# Before starting Issue #59 development:") print("python tools/requirements_engineering_toolkit.py analyze") print("") print("# Plan new interface evolution:") print("python tools/requirements_engineering_toolkit.py plan-interface --interface IssueBackend") print("") print("# Generate development checklist:") print("python tools/requirements_engineering_toolkit.py checklist --feature 'Issue Management CLI'") print("") print("# Validate test mocks:") print("python tools/requirements_engineering_toolkit.py validate-mocks --test-file tests/test_issue_59_cli_interface.py") print("\n๐Ÿ“ Integration with existing workflow:") print("# Add to Makefile:") print("validate-requirements:") print("\tpython tools/requirements_engineering_toolkit.py analyze") print("") print("tdd-start: validate-requirements") print("\t# Existing TDD start process") def main(): """Run the complete demonstration.""" print("ISSUE #59 PREVENTION DEMONSTRATION") print("Requirements Engineering Agent") print("=" * 60) try: demonstrate_issue_59_problems() demonstrate_requirements_engineering_solution() demonstrate_interface_compatibility_checking() demonstrate_correct_development_workflow() create_agent_usage_example() print("\n\n๐ŸŽ‰ SUMMARY") print("=" * 20) print("The Requirements Engineering Agent would have prevented Issue #59 problems by:") print("1. โœ… Analyzing existing domain models before writing tests") print("2. โœ… Ensuring mocks match actual object interfaces") print("3. โœ… Catching enum vs string type mismatches") print("4. โœ… Identifying missing async adapter layer") print("5. โœ… Planning interface evolution with backward compatibility") print("6. โœ… Providing clear development workflow guidance") except Exception as e: print(f"Error in demonstration: {e}") print("Note: This demo requires the full project structure to run completely.") print("The concepts and workflow are demonstrated above.") if __name__ == "__main__": main()