Cross-dive synthesis (research/260614-shard-spectrum-synthesis/) reading
the two Nelson conceptual systems, four engines, and three modern tools
across each other: a shard family matrix and eleven capability spectra
(addressing, content identity, structure, history, native query,
translation, attachment mode, operational envelope, access grant, write
granularity, content types) — positions anchored at both ends by a real
system, federation ops degrading by position. Through-lines:
files-canonical/index-derived wins; fine-grained addressing is adoptable;
transclusion=clone=embed is one primitive; structure/history federate iff
in-text; attach mode is a per-binding choice; Notion proves the platform
can enforce no-silent-mutation.
Folded into SHARD-WP-0002: T11 reframed around the eleven spectra; T12
page model stretched four ways (prose + typed records + non-Markdown
assets + query-defined); T13 adds Notion supplement; T14 rewritten as the
three-mode attachment taxonomy (file-store / in-engine-host /
external-API); T15 adds lossy-with-fidelity-report; new T16 (addressing,
content identity, dimensional/query navigation). UC coverage UC-34-43 ->
UC-34-59. Workplan now 16 tasks. No new UCs (synthesis only).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The closed/hosted/schema-rich extreme: everything is a block (UUID id,
type, properties, ordered child content, single parent), pages are blocks
and database rows are pages with a schema, Postgres-backed hosted SaaS.
Databases add typed properties + relations + rollups + formulas across
many views = the apex of wiki-page-as-structured-record. Extension model
has no in-app plugin runtime; the only extensibility is the external REST
API (+ webhooks 2026) inside a tight envelope (~3 rps, eventual
consistency, recursive child fetch, scoped/revocable per-page grants).
Adds the third attachment mode (external-API-only) alongside file-store
(Obsidian/TWiki) and in-engine host (Roam/XWiki); Notion enforces no
silent remote mutation via scoped grants. Added UC-57 (attach closed
external-API-only shard w/ operational envelope + scoped grant), UC-58
(typed database w/ schema+relations+views, no flattening), UC-59
(lossy-aware translation w/ fidelity report); enriched
UC-31/34/36/39/50/51/52/54/56. Boundary: one external-API candidate shard,
best as projection/mirror/overlay/backup, not a substrate and not the
federation layer.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The most INTENT-aligned tool yet and the file-backed counterpart to Roam:
file-over-app vaults (plain .md folders, files canonical, MetadataCache a
derived index), in-file git-diffable addressing/structure (^block-id,
wikilink embeds, YAML frontmatter), and a plugin API (Plugin onload/onunload
over App.vault/metadataCache/workspace) that doubles as an adapter host —
so a vault is dual-attachable (file-store direct or in-app plugin). Mined
the plugin download rankings as demand evidence per the research brief:
#1 is drawings (Excalidraw, non-Markdown content), query-as-DB
(Dataview/Tasks) is top-tier but an add-on, Git is top-7 (bolt-on history),
Remotely Save shows sync-to-anywhere demand. Added UC-53 (attach local
vault w/ live concurrent native editor), UC-54 (query-defined dynamic
page), UC-55 (non-Markdown content types), UC-56 (outbound publish of a
projection); enriched UC-15/28/34/36/40/51/52. Boundary: a vault is one
file-backed candidate shard, not the federation layer and not a file-sync
target.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The modern bookend to the Xanadu/ZigZag dives: where those are unbuilt
ideals, Roam shipped fine-grained addressing (:block/uid), live
transclusion (block embeds), bidirectional links, and a queryable
structured space (DataScript datoms + Datalog). Studied as a candidate
DB-backed/API-attached shard (XWiki family) and as a concrete
engine-hosts-adapter surface (Roam Depot onload/onunload over
window.roamAlphaAPI). Added UC-50 (attach block-graph DB shard, block<->page
mapping), UC-51 (adopt native span IDs as portable span addresses), UC-52
(delegate derived views to a shard's native query engine); enriched
UC-32/34/35/38. Boundary: Roam is one candidate shard mapped into the
Markdown-first page model, not a substrate and not the federation layer.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Evaluated modelling a wiki information space as a zzstructure: a page is
a cell at the intersection of many co-equal dimensions (namespace tree,
created-from genealogy, version, shard, equivalence, links).
Recommendation: adopt zzstructure as a navigation/visualization/indexing
LENS (a derived dimensional projection over the union), not as the
storage substrate — Git and sovereign shards stay canonical, and the
many-to-many link graph does not fit the one-neighbour-per-dimension rank
rule. Clone <-> transclusion convergence with the Xanadu dive. Added
UC-47/48/49; enriched UC-05/22/26/29; dimensional projection layer +
genealogy-edges-in-journal logged as architecture for SHARD-WP-0002.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Xanadu studied as conceptual ancestor, not a candidate shard. Yield:
reference-not-copy EDL/xanadoc validates projection+overlay+union;
content-identity bidirectional transclusion; portable span-address
(tumbler) problem logged as adapter-contract architecture for
SHARD-WP-0002. Recorded design-bug boundaries: reject
single-global-docuverse, single-canonical-instance, baked-in economic
policy. Added UC-44/45/46; enriched UC-24/27/29/32.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Document Federated Wiki mechanics (fork, journal, inverted browser model),
Caulfield lifecycle concepts, and comparison with git-backed wikis,
ActivityPub/XWiki, Xanadu patterns, and yawex REMOTE/VIRTUAL. Map
findings to shard-wiki INTENT without equating fedwiki to orchestration.
Explores WikiWikiWeb beginnings: design principles, social conventions,
navigation vocabulary, and documented use cases. Federation explicitly
deferred to a later research track.
