whynot-control/agent-tasks/review-signals-and-draft-decision.md

Agent Task: Review Signals And Draft Decision

Goal

Turn prototype and beta evidence into a clear signal review and draft promotion decision.

Context

Signals are evidence, not enthusiasm. MARKET_SIGNAL.md defines strength levels, and PROTOTYPE_PIPELINE.md requires an explicit decision before promotion.

Inputs

• A prototype card
• Any related beta notes or beta plan
• Signal notes or records
• MARKET_SIGNAL.md
• templates/signal-record.md
• templates/promotion-decision.md

Allowed Changes

• Create or refine signal records in signals/.
• Summarize beta feedback faithfully.
• Draft a promotion decision for later human review.

Forbidden Changes

• Do not upgrade weak evidence into strong signal.
• Do not hide contradictory evidence.
• Do not mark promotion as final without explicit approval.

Expected Output

• A signal summary with strength assessment.
• A draft decision: promote, iterate, park, reject, or merge.

Acceptance Criteria

• Evidence and counter-evidence are both represented.
• The recommendation matches the recorded signal strength.
• The proposed next step is explicit.

Human Approval Required For

• Final promotion into another initiative.
• Any external-facing launch or commercial claim.