infospace-bench/infospaces/lefevre-reminiscences-of-a-stock-operator/workflows/templates/trading-literature/evaluate-entity.md

Evaluate Trading-Literature Entity

Profile: {{ macros.profile }}

Evaluate the generated entity as Markdown with YAML frontmatter. Include artifact_id, evaluator, evaluated_at, and a scores list. Score each criterion on a 0 to 5 scale where 5 is best.

Required score names:

• groundedness — does the entity stay anchored to the source chunk, with no invented dates, dollar figures, or quotes?
• lesson_clarity — for strategy, error, psychological_pattern, and evidence_bearing_claim entities, is the operator-level lesson stated crisply enough to be reused in later chapters? For purely factual entities (trader, market, institution, instrument), score this on the clarity of the definition.
• historical_context — is the entity placed correctly in the era and venue of the source (e.g. early-1900s American equities) without importing modern terminology or instruments?
• overgeneralization_risk — is the entity scoped narrowly enough to resist becoming a vague universal claim? Higher score means lower risk. Flag entities that quietly claim to apply to all markets or all operators when the source restricts the claim.

Add a short ## Review Notes section listing any specific lines from the entity body that drove a low score on any criterion.

Entity artifact: {{ input.artifact_id }} Entity title: {{ input.title }}

Entity

{{ input.content }}