New assessment of CMIS functionality

This commit is contained in:
2026-05-14 00:15:12 +02:00
parent b11c9189e4
commit 637d1ec20e
2 changed files with 39 additions and 4 deletions

View File

@@ -72,14 +72,17 @@ CMIS interoperability importance rather than engine-internal importance.
| Metric | Score |
| --- | ---: |
| OpenCMIS selected-baseline infrastructure score | 98.3% |
| Weighted CMIS 1.1 depth vs Hyland Alfresco benchmark | 59% |
| Controlled-client Browser Binding usefulness | 80% |
| Broad commodity CMIS client compatibility | 54% |
Interpretation: the current CMIS layer is a credible Browser Binding subset for
known clients and profile-specific integrations, especially around repository,
type, object, folder, content, move/copy, and controlled mutation workflows. It
is not yet a broad ECM/CMIS replacement surface.
Interpretation: the OpenCMIS infrastructure score measures the selected
`repository-type` and `object-content` harness baseline only. The current CMIS
layer is a credible Browser Binding subset for known clients and
profile-specific integrations, especially around repository, type, object,
folder, content, move/copy, and controlled mutation workflows. It is not yet a
broad ECM/CMIS replacement surface.
## Capability Scorecard

View File

@@ -29,6 +29,38 @@ Guide Board summary:
- `pass`: 1
- `warning`: 2
## OpenCMIS Infrastructure Score
This is a compatibility-infrastructure score for the selected Browser Binding
baseline, not a CMIS certification score and not the broader product-depth
score from `docs/cmis-1-1-capability-scorecard.md`.
Formula:
- Accepted case = `pass`, `info`, or declared `skipped`.
- Warning case = half credit.
- Hard blocker = `fail`, `infrastructure_error`, or unexpected finding.
Scores:
| Metric | Score | Basis |
| --- | ---: | --- |
| Selected baseline completion | 100.0% | Guide Board result `completed`; both selected groups returned `0`. |
| Unexpected finding clearance | 100.0% | `0` unexpected findings, `0` fail, `0` infrastructure_error. |
| Warning-adjusted normalized case score | 98.3% | `(56 accepted + 0.5 * 2 warnings) / 58 normalized cases`. |
| Strict no-warning normalized case score | 96.6% | `56 accepted / 58 normalized cases`. |
Digest versus the previous WP-0014 object/content frontier
(`run-20260508T164334Z`):
- Overall OpenCMIS status improved from `infrastructure_error` to `completed`.
- Object/content hard blockers improved from `3 fail` and
`3 infrastructure_error` to `0 fail` and `0 infrastructure_error`.
- Object/content warnings improved from `3 warning` to `1 warning`.
- The old remaining blockers were closed: CMIS exception mapping,
`bulkUpdateProperties`, `deleteContentStream`, change-token conflict
handling, copy/create-from-source, and offset-zero range classification.
## Blocker Resolution
Resolved in this pass: