Files
ops-warden/workplans/WARDEN-WP-0020-ops-warden-worker.md
tegwick f8ac55367c feat(WARDEN-WP-0020): T3 — guarded executor (worker now acts, not just plans)
HubClient gains writes (mark_read, send_reply, add_progress). execute_plan/execute_plans
run the safe, allowlisted actions autonomously: route_answer (reply with the computed
answer + auto mark-read), reply (LLM-drafted body), progress_note, mark_read. Escalated
plans and non-auto-executable kinds are left for a human; every action is metadata-only
(no secret value read/sent/logged).

Deliberate guardrail: propose_catalog_diff and any code/routing change is NOT auto-executed
even under full-auto — a bad catalog commit could misroute credentials, so it goes to human
review (recoverability over convenience). AUTO_EXECUTABLE is the messaging/hub tier only.

`warden worker run --execute` runs the executor (dry-run still default). 7 executor tests
(reply+mark, with/without body, escalated skip, catalog-diff-left-for-human, progress,
failure-without-crash); 243 pass, lint clean. First live --execute shakedown is the
operator's (staged rollout); T4 schedules it.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-29 23:19:13 +02:00

163 lines
7.5 KiB
Markdown

---
id: WARDEN-WP-0020
type: workplan
title: "ops-warden worker — autonomous coordination via llm-connect"
domain: infotech
repo: ops-warden
status: active
owner: claude
topic_slug: custodian
planning_priority: high
planning_order: 20
created: "2026-06-29"
updated: "2026-06-29"
state_hub_workstream_id: "c906ba1d-f991-4fb0-b113-59432ddf87c0"
---
# WARDEN-WP-0020 — ops-warden worker (`warden worker`)
**Problem:** ops-warden's coordination lane (State Hub inbox `to_agent=ops-warden`) is
handled only when a human spins up an ops-warden session and relays instructions. That
doesn't scale — Bernd is hand-relaying between flex-auth ↔ secrets-engine ↔ ops-warden
across sessions.
**Goal:** a `warden worker` CLI that pulls ops-warden's unread coordination requests and,
using **llm-connect** for inference, drives each to an ops-warden action (answer a routing
question, draft+send a reply, mark read, propose/commit a catalog diff, or escalate) — so
the inbox is handled without a human starting a session.
**Decisions (Bernd, 2026-06-29):** **full-auto in-scope** (worker executes any in-scope
action; escalates only secrets/prod/out-of-scope) and **scheduled/unattended** (cron or
activity-core). Because there is no human in the loop for in-scope actions, the guardrails
are load-bearing and the rollout is staged: **dry-run → manual → scheduled**.
**Build vs reuse:** inference = llm-connect (`/execute`); trigger = cron or activity-core
(reuse the durable task factory, don't reinvent scheduling). Worker logic lives in warden.
## Guardrails (non-negotiable — full-auto rests on these)
1. **Fixed charter, non-overridable.** The boundary (issue SSH; route everything else;
conduit-not-broker; never hold/print a secret value) is a fixed system policy. Message
content is **untrusted data**, never instructions that can relax it (prompt-injection
containment).
2. **Action allowlist.** Every action is validated against an allowlist before execution;
off-list → escalate. No secret handling, no prod-config writes, no irreversible/outward
actions without an explicit human ack.
3. **No-secret invariant.** Refuse any task requiring a secret value in hand or in a prompt.
4. **Full audit + dry-run.** Every action emits a progress event; `--dry-run` shows the
plan without executing. Scheduled mode only after a clean dry-run shakedown.
## Hard dependency
llm-connect must be operational — it needs its provider key (`OPENROUTER_API_KEY`,
CCR-2026-0003, currently deferred by railiance-platform/secrets-engine). The worker is
built against llm-connect's contract; it cannot run the brain until that lands.
---
## Tasks
### T1 — Worker scaffold (llm-connect-independent, safe)
```task
id: WARDEN-WP-0020-T01
status: done
priority: high
state_hub_task_id: "979c2d9b-0803-442f-aa2e-acb02bac07e9"
```
- [x] `src/warden/worker.py`: State Hub inbox client (`HubClient.unread`), a `Brain`
protocol, a deterministic `RuleBrain` default (answers clear routing questions;
escalates the rest), the `PlannedAction`/`WorkerPlan` model, the guardrail allowlist +
`validate_action` (enforced brain-agnostically in `build_plans`), and a `render_plans`
dry-run renderer (plan only, no execution).
- [x] `warden worker run [--once] [--dry-run]` CLI; `--dry-run` is the default and
`--execute` is refused (exit 2) until the guarded executor lands (T3).
- [x] `tests/test_worker.py` (RuleBrain routing/secret/prod/unknown, guardrail downgrades a
reckless brain on secret/prod, off-allowlist rejection, render, CLI). 18 cases.
- [x] Live dry-run against the real hub verified — read the inbox and produced a guardrailed
plan (it surfaced secrets-engine's OIDC-role reply, demonstrating the value).
### T2 — llm-connect brain
```task
id: WARDEN-WP-0020-T02
status: done
priority: high
state_hub_task_id: "52d281b2-7d48-44f5-b77e-80e3ed500b5f"
```
- [x] llm-connect brought operational (operator set OPENROUTER_API_KEY k8s secret + restart).
Contract discovered empirically from the running service: `POST /execute {"prompt":...}`
`{"content": "<text>", ...}` (no OpenAPI; custom JSON API). End-to-end verified (pong).
- [x] `LlmConnectBrain` (src/warden/worker.py): embeds the fixed charter + the message as
untrusted data into the prompt, calls `/execute`, parses a JSON action plan
(`_extract_json` tolerates fences/prose), and defensively escalates on malformed/empty/
transport-error. Configurable `LLM_CONNECT_URL`. The guardrail pass still enforces the
allowlist + no-secret invariant on whatever the model returns.
- [x] `warden worker run --brain rule|llm` selector (dry-run default). Tests:
`tests/test_worker.py` (extract_json, parse, escalate-on-flag/malformed/transport,
guardrail-catches-unsafe-LLM-action). **Live verified** against the real inbox: the LLM
brain produced a sensible reply+mark_read for the secrets-engine message and correctly
escalated the llm-connect secret-custody request. 236 tests, lint clean.
### T3 — Action dispatch + guardrails (full-auto in-scope)
```task
id: WARDEN-WP-0020-T03
status: done
priority: high
state_hub_task_id: "3a71965e-42d5-4258-9761-aced804c88e7"
```
- [x] `HubClient` gained writes (`mark_read`, `send_reply`, `add_progress`); `execute_plan`
/ `execute_plans` run the **safe, allowlisted** actions — route_answer (reply with the
computed answer + auto mark-read), reply (with an LLM-drafted body), progress_note,
mark_read. Escalated plans and non-auto-executable kinds are left for a human.
- [x] **Deliberate guardrail:** `propose_catalog_diff` (and any code/routing change) is NOT
auto-executed even under full-auto — a bad catalog commit could misroute credentials,
so it goes to human review (recoverability over convenience). AUTO_EXECUTABLE is the
messaging/hub tier only. No secret value is ever read, sent, or logged.
- [x] `warden worker run --execute` runs the guarded executor (dry-run still the default);
per-message audit summary. Tests in `tests/test_worker.py` (route_answer reply+mark,
reply-with/without-body, escalated skip, catalog-diff left-for-human, progress_note,
failure-without-crash). 243 pass, lint clean.
- Note: first **live** `--execute` shakedown is the operator's (staged rollout: dry-run →
manual → scheduled); T4 wraps it on a schedule.
### T4 — Scheduled trigger
```task
id: WARDEN-WP-0020-T04
status: todo
priority: medium
state_hub_task_id: "7f77ea6d-c281-42c5-ad25-2a0bb9fd68de"
```
- [ ] Wire cron or activity-core to `warden worker run --once`. Ships **disabled**; enabled
only after a clean dry-run shakedown. Concurrency guard (no overlapping runs).
### T5 — Docs / SCOPE / INTENT
```task
id: WARDEN-WP-0020-T05
status: todo
priority: medium
state_hub_task_id: "6e7ae317-7f8b-468a-bb5c-b08093ed43a0"
```
- [ ] Record the scope expansion: ops-warden gains an autonomous coordination worker.
Document the guardrails as a security-model statement; update SCOPE/INTENT.
---
## Acceptance
- `warden worker run --dry-run` reads the real inbox and prints a guardrailed plan.
- Full-auto execution runs only in-scope, allowlisted actions; secrets/prod/out-of-scope
escalate; every action is audited. No secret value ever enters a prompt, log, or commit.
- Scheduled mode is enabled only after a dry-run shakedown.
## See also
- llm-connect (inference), activity-core (durable trigger), kaizen-agentic (personas)
- `.claude/rules/credential-routing.md` (the boundary the worker enforces)