feat(adr): add ADR-003 (5-repo OAS stack); supersede ADR-002

ADR-003 formalises the 5-repo structure aligned with OAS Stack S1-S5:
railiance-infra, railiance-cluster, railiance-platform,
railiance-enablement, railiance-apps. Defines boundary rule, pre-condition
chain, and content relocation table. ADR-002 marked superseded.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-03-10 00:27:18 +01:00
parent d9f6848a5b
commit a680fb51af
2 changed files with 105 additions and 1 deletions

View File

@@ -1,7 +1,8 @@
# ADR-002 — Repository Boundary: railiance-hosts vs railiance-bootstrap
**Status:** Accepted
**Status:** Superseded by ADR-003
**Date:** 2026-03-09
**Superseded:** 2026-03-10 — see `ADR-003-railiance-5repo-stack-architecture.md`
**Deciders:** Bernd Worsch
---

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,103 @@
# ADR-003 — Railiance 5-Repo Stack Architecture
**Status:** Accepted
**Date:** 2026-03-10
**Deciders:** Bernd Worsch
**Supersedes:** ADR-002 (repo-boundary-hosts-vs-bootstrap)
---
## Context
ADR-002 defined a two-repo boundary between `railiance-hosts` (OS baseline)
and `railiance-bootstrap` (Kubernetes layer). As the railiance tooling expands
to cover platform services, developer enablement, and application deployments,
a two-repo model is insufficient and the naming no longer signals stack position.
The **Orthogonal Architecture Standard** (OAS v1.0,
`canon/standards/orthogonal-architecture_v1.0.md`) defines six canonical
dimensions. The Stack dimension (S1S5) provides a natural, self-documenting
structure for the railiance tooling.
---
## Decision
### One repo per Stack level
The railiance toolset is structured as five repositories, each owning exactly
one OAS Stack level:
| OAS Level | Repository | Responsibility |
|-----------|------------|----------------|
| S1 Infrastructure Substrate | `railiance-infra` | OS provisioning, security hardening, Ansible roles, Goss spec + test suite, Terraform, inventory, secrets |
| S2 Cluster Runtime | `railiance-cluster` | k3s, Helm, ingress, CNI, admission controllers, operators, kubeconfig management |
| S3 Platform Services | `railiance-platform` | PostgreSQL HA, object storage, secret management, identity, message brokers, caches |
| S4 Developer Enablement | `railiance-enablement` | CI/CD pipelines, developer portal, platform templates, SDKs, buildpacks |
| S5 Workloads & Experience | `railiance-apps` | Application Helm releases, Kubernetes manifests for user-facing services (Gitea, coulomb apps) |
### Naming rationale
The name of each repo encodes its OAS Stack level. A reader seeing the repo
list immediately knows the stack position without reading documentation.
`railiance-enablement` is preferred over `railiance-dev` to avoid ambiguity
with "development environment."
### Boundary rule
> **Every file, playbook, and configuration belongs in exactly one repo,
> determined by the OAS Stack level of the concern it addresses.**
The authoritative reference for whether a concern belongs at a given Stack
level is `canon/standards/orthogonal-architecture_v1.0.md` §5 (Stack
Dimension Specification).
### Pre-condition chain
Each layer depends on the layer below being converged and verified:
```
railiance-infra (make converge + make verify)
→ railiance-cluster (k3s install + smoke test)
→ railiance-platform (platform services deployed)
→ railiance-enablement (CI/CD and tooling active)
→ railiance-apps (application deployments)
```
No layer may re-configure concerns owned by a lower layer.
---
## Content relocations from railiance-cluster
The following items existed in `railiance-bootstrap` (now `railiance-cluster`)
but belong at other Stack levels and are relocated as part of this ADR:
| Item | Relocated to | OAS Level | Reason |
|------|-------------|-----------|--------|
| `cloudinit/user-data.yaml` | `railiance-infra` | S1 | Cloud-init is node provisioning |
| `tools/cmd/railiance-plan-host` | `railiance-infra` | S1 | Host planning is infrastructure scope |
| `tools/cmd/railiance-backup` | `railiance-platform` | S3 | Backup is a platform service concern |
---
## Consequences
- `railiance-infra` and `railiance-cluster` are renames; git history is
preserved.
- `railiance-platform`, `railiance-enablement`, and `railiance-apps` are new
repos, initially containing only scaffolding (CLAUDE.md, Makefile, workplans/).
- State Hub `ManagedRepo` slugs are updated from the old names to the new ones.
- All CLAUDE.md, Makefile, and workplan files in the renamed repos are updated
to reflect the new names.
- ADR-002 is superseded and should not be used as an authoritative reference.
Its boundary table is incorporated and extended here.
---
## Superseded ADR
ADR-002 (`ADR-002-repo-boundary-hosts-vs-bootstrap.md`) is superseded by
this document. Its core rule — that items defined in `spec/server-baseline.yaml`
must not be managed by `railiance-cluster` — remains in force and is
generalised here: no layer may manage concerns owned by a layer below it.