Compare commits

...

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
00469c4cc0 Adopt whynot-design tokens (WP-0017 Phase 1)
Replace vergabe's blue brand-* palette with whynot's near-black/paper/yellow
visual language. Tokens vendored at static/src/vendor/whynot-design/ (synced
from commit 9419f16 via scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh / make sync-whynot-design).

main.css imports the vendored CSS first, exposes ink/paper/hi as Tailwind
@theme tokens (bg-paper, text-ink, border-line, etc.), and re-tones every
component class (.btn-*, .card, .field-row, .phase-*, .form-input, .table-*,
.sidebar-*). Border radii drop to whynot's 0-4px; .card loses its shadow.

Legacy text-brand-* / bg-brand-* / border-brand-* template references are
kept working via @theme aliases that map the old blue scale onto the whynot
ink ramp — Phase 1 is tokens-only, no template churn.

btn-danger keeps an off-spec red (#B22222) as a local --danger var until
upstream defines a canonical destructive color.

base.html body class swapped: bg-slate-50 → bg-paper-2 text-ink.

Phase 2 (component adoption) deferred until whynot-design ships Lit web
components + missing atoms (Card, Modal, Input, Table, Toast). See
wiki/DesignSystem.md and history/2026-05-23-whynot-design-cross-framework-analysis.md.

Verified: 8/8 e2e tests pass; dev server boots; static/dist/main.css contains
no #3b5bdb references. Visual pixel-level verification still pending Bernd's
browser walk.
2026-05-23 21:52:59 +02:00
fbb8def9ce Plan WP-0017: whynot-design adoption (tokens + CSS only)
Add cross-framework analysis to history/ and WP-0017 workplan for the
tokens+CSS phase of adopting ~/whynot-design. Component port deferred until
upstream ships Lit web components and missing atoms (Card, Modal, Input,
Table, Toast).

Decisions captured: vendor (not npm), big-bang swap (not pilot), keep
off-spec red for btn-danger until upstream defines one.
2026-05-23 19:09:18 +02:00
14 changed files with 1318 additions and 41 deletions

View File

@@ -1,19 +1,32 @@
## Stack
<!-- TODO: Fill in language, frameworks, and key dependencies -->
- **Language:**
- **Key deps:**
- **Language:** Python 3.12 (Django 6), Node 22 (Vite + Tailwind v4)
- **Key deps:** Django, htmx, Alpine.js, Tailwind v4, whynot-design (vendored
under `static/src/vendor/whynot-design/`)
## Dev Commands
```bash
# TODO: Fill in the standard commands for this repo
# Install dependencies
uv sync # Python
npm ci # Node (Vite/Tailwind)
# Run tests
# Run dev stack
make db # Start postgres if not running
make dev # Django runserver on :9000
make css # Tailwind/Vite watcher (rebuilds main.css)
# Lint / type check
# Build CSS bundle for prod / for verification
npm run build # → static/dist/main.css
# Build / package (if applicable)
# Re-vendor the whynot-design system from a pinned upstream commit
make sync-whynot-design # reads .whynot-design-ref by default
# or: ./scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh <ref>
# Tests / lint
make test # uv run pytest
make lint # ruff + mypy
```
See `wiki/DesignSystem.md` for the whynot-design adoption status (Phase 1
tokens+CSS done; Phase 2 components deferred) and local style conventions.

View File

@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
.PHONY: help db dev css seed migrate test lint shell superuser collectstatic
.PHONY: help db dev css seed migrate test lint shell superuser collectstatic sync-whynot-design
.DEFAULT_GOAL := help
@@ -41,3 +41,6 @@ shell: ## Open a Django shell (shell_plus if available)
collectstatic: ## Collect static files into staticfiles/ (production step)
uv run manage.py collectstatic --noinput
sync-whynot-design: ## Re-vendor whynot-design CSS+tokens from the pinned ref
./scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,361 @@
---
date: 2026-05-23
topic: whynot-design adoption — cross-framework analysis
status: research / decision pending
author: claude (opus-4.7)
related:
- ~/whynot-design (the React DS in question)
- ~/whynot-control (the org control surface — explicitly out of scope)
- vergabe-teilnahme (the consuming Django app)
follow-ups:
- workplan: VERGABE_TEILNAHME-WP-0017 (whynot-design adoption) — not yet drafted, depends on strategy decision below
- possible new repo: whynot-design-django — see §5
---
# whynot-design — cross-framework adoption analysis
> Persisted from a research conversation on 2026-05-23. The conversation was triggered
> by the question "should vergabe-teilnahme adopt the whynot design system, and how?"
> The strategic question opened up because whynot-design ships React components
> while vergabe-teilnahme is Django + HTMX + Tailwind.
## 1. The headline insight
There is **no community** around "React → Django component porting." That pattern
doesn't exist as a tool, library, or codified practice. The reason: cross-framework
UI sharing has, since ~2020, converged on **Web Components** as the standard answer.
Every major design system that supports multiple frameworks (Shoelace / Web Awesome,
IBM Carbon, Adobe Spectrum, Salesforce Lightning, Material Web) either ships Web
Components or maintains parallel hand-rolled implementations per framework. There is
no third option that the industry has validated.
The W3C Design Tokens Community Group spec reached its **first stable version in
October 2025**, with Style Dictionary, Figma, Penpot, Tokens Studio, and others as
reference implementations. Tokens as a cross-framework contract are now genuinely
portable; *components* still aren't, except via web components.
The strategic question therefore reshapes itself: **do we accept the
parallel-implementations cost, or do we change what `whynot-design` actually ships?**
## 2. Research findings — existing approaches and their communities
| Approach | What it is | Community / activity | Fit for whynot |
|---|---|---|---|
| **Web Components** (Lit, Stencil) | Browser-standard custom elements; works in any framework | Very active; React 19 finally scores perfect on custom-elements-everywhere.com | **High** — best general answer if we're willing to refactor whynot-design |
| **Shoelace / Web Awesome** | Pre-built Web Components UI kit (Shoelace's successor) | Large, active OSS community | Not direct (competing DS), but proves the model. Has explicit HTMX integration guides |
| **Stencil JS** | Compiler that emits framework-specific bindings from one source | Mature; IBM/Apple use it; declining mindshare vs. Lit | **Medium** — heavier than Lit but generates per-framework wrappers automatically |
| **Style Dictionary + DTCG tokens** | One token file → CSS / Tailwind / iOS / Android / Flutter | W3C-backed, stable spec since 2025-10 | **High** — should be our token pipeline regardless of component choice |
| **Carbon / Spectrum / Lightning / Material pattern** | Single design source, hand-maintained parallel packages per framework | Active but they're 100+ engineer teams | **Low** at our scale — the "expensive but principled" reference path |
| **Single-spa / micro-frontends** | Multiple frameworks coexisting in one app | Niche, mostly enterprise integration | **Off-topic** — not about sharing components, about hosting heterogeneous apps |
| **django-cotton / django-components / django-bird** | Django-template-native component libraries; HTMX-friendly | Active, growing in 20242026; mature enough to depend on | **High** as the *Django-side runtime* — but doesn't solve cross-framework, just gives Django a real component model |
| **"Port React to Django" libraries** | (doesn't exist) | None | None |
**Read of the field:** the world has settled on "tokens are cross-framework;
components are framework-native." Most teams either pick web components (one
implementation, runs anywhere with some friction) or accept parallel implementations
from a shared design language.
## 3. Three viable strategies for whynot's situation
**Strategy A — Pivot whynot-design to Web Components.**
Rewrite `Atoms.jsx` + `Chrome.jsx` as Lit components. Ship one runtime artefact
(`@whynot/design`) that Django + HTMX templates can drop into a page via plain
`<whynot-button>` tags. No React dependency anywhere. Tailwind / CSS variables
continue to drive theming.
**Strategy B — Keep whynot-design React-canonical; add a parallel `whynot-design-django` repo.**
Treat the React JSX as the *visual + API specification*. Hand-port to Django
partials in a separate, reusable repo so vergabe-teilnahme and future Django
consumers share one implementation. Tokens stay in whynot-design (single source).
**Strategy C — Tokens only; components are framework-local forever.**
Don't promise component parity. Vergabe re-implements whynot's *look* using the
tokens but its components live and die in vergabe-teilnahme. Other Django apps
would do the same fork. Bernd implied this is unsatisfying — he wants a real
component library for cross-project consistency.
The real choice is **A vs. B**.
## 4. Pros / cons — A (Web Components) vs. B (parallel Django repo)
### Strategy A — Pivot to Web Components (Lit)
**Pros**
- *One* implementation. Zero divergence risk. Bug fixes ship once.
- Standards-backed; outlives any framework choice. Works in vanilla HTML, Django
templates, future Vue/Svelte/Solid apps, marketing sites, claude.ai artifacts.
- HTMX swaps work cleanly — web components are just DOM; HTMX doesn't care.
- The community is *here*. Tutorials, debugging tools, Storybook integration,
accessibility testing infrastructure all exist.
- The Claude atelier in claude.ai can still output JSX prototypes; Lit ports are
mechanical once the design is decided.
**Cons**
- One-time rewrite cost of the existing 11 React components. Real, but small
(~267 lines of JSX, not a library of 200 components).
- Web components have Shadow DOM trade-offs: form-association, deep style scoping,
and slotting have learning curves. Workable but real friction.
- React-shaped APIs (`<Button variant="primary">`) translate to attributes /
properties (`<wn-button variant="primary">`). Slightly less ergonomic in React,
equally ergonomic everywhere else.
- Lose the claude.ai → npm symmetry: claude.ai design tool outputs JSX; you'd
convert each new component.
- Whoever maintains whynot-design has to learn Lit (small surface area, but new
vocabulary).
### Strategy B — Parallel `whynot-design-django` repo
**Pros**
- Each implementation is idiomatic for its stack. Django templates feel like
Django; React feels like React.
- No new technology to learn. Both repos use mature, well-understood patterns.
- Django consumers get to use `django-cotton` or `django-bird` — real ergonomics,
not a half-port.
- claude.ai → JSX → Lit conversion step is avoided. The atelier output is
*directly* the React reference.
**Cons**
- *Two* implementations forever. Every component change needs both sides updated;
PRs need cross-repo review discipline.
- API drift is inevitable. By v0.5 the React `<Button>` and Django `{% button %}`
will have diverged in props/slots/behavior unless enforced with conformance tests.
- A *third* consumer stack (Vue, vanilla HTML, native mobile) means a *third* repo.
Cost scales linearly with the number of stacks; A's cost is roughly constant.
- The "community" of "people maintaining a React→Django twin DS" is exactly Bernd
and whoever he recruits. No prior art to lean on.
- Visual regression testing has to run twice (Playwright against examples in both
repos) to ensure parity.
### Recommendation
**Strategy A is the right long-term answer**; B is the right *interim* answer if
we don't want to halt vergabe-teilnahme to do a Lit rewrite first.
A real third path: **A scheduled, B today.** Build B as a reusable Django port now
to unblock vergabe-teilnahme; treat it as the *bridge* until whynot-design pivots
to Lit at, say, v0.5. The Django repo becomes obsolete when A lands — that's a
feature, not a bug; it forces a clear retirement decision instead of accumulating
tech debt.
If we don't want to commit to a future Lit pivot, then B is the right choice on its
own — just accept the linear-cost-per-stack reality.
## 5. Naming, establishing, workflow — if we go with B
### Naming proposals
| Candidate | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| **`whynot-design-django`** (recommended) | Mirrors `@whynot/design`. Unambiguous about stack. Discoverable. | Slightly long. |
| `whynot-django` | Short. | Ambiguous — sounds like a Django app, not a DS port. |
| `whynot-design-py` | Hedges for Jinja2/Flask later. | Vague — Python doesn't pick a template engine. |
| `whynot-dj` | Compact. | Cryptic. |
| `whynot-templates` | Honest about what it is. | Doesn't carry the "design" meaning. |
**Recommend `whynot-design-django`.** If a Jinja port appears, it gets its own repo
(`whynot-design-jinja`), not a confusing rename.
### Establishing the repo (concrete steps)
1. **Gitea org placement:** `gitea-remote:whynot/whynot-design-django.git` — same
org as `whynot-design`, signaling sibling status.
2. **Package shape:** a pip-installable Django app (`pyproject.toml`, importable as
`whynot_design`). Two install paths:
- `pip install git+ssh://...@v0.1.0` (matches whynot-design's tag-pinned discipline).
- For dev: editable install (`pip install -e ../whynot-design-django`).
3. **Layout** (matches Django conventions; mirrors whynot-design's structure):
```
whynot-design-django/
├── README.md ← restates the "match the React spec" contract
├── CONTRIBUTING.md ← parity rules: any change here must follow a whynot-design change
├── CHANGELOG.md
├── pyproject.toml
├── whynot_design/
│ ├── __init__.py
│ ├── apps.py
│ ├── templates/whynot_design/
│ │ ├── atoms/eyebrow.html, tag.html, button.html, stage_dot.html, stamp.html, icon.html
│ │ ├── chrome/top_nav.html, sidebar.html, page_header.html, pipeline_strip.html
│ │ └── _base.html ← imports the CSS once
│ ├── templatetags/
│ │ └── whynot.py ← {% wn_button variant="primary" %}…{% endwn_button %}, etc.
│ └── static/whynot_design/
│ └── colors_and_type.css ← vendored from @whynot/design (synced)
├── tests/
│ ├── test_components.py ← Django test client, asserts rendered markup matches expected shape
│ └── parity/ ← Playwright comparison of Django render vs. React render
└── examples/ ← a Django demo project rendering every component
```
4. **Token sync:** a `scripts/sync-from-whynot-design.py` that copies
`colors_and_type.css` and `tokens/*.json` from a pinned whynot-design ref into
the static dir + generates a Django settings constant for tokens. Run on every
whynot-design version bump.
5. **Underlying component mechanism:** plain `{% include %}` partials (simplest, no
new dep), `django-cotton` (HTML-like syntax, very ergonomic, active community),
or `django-components` (most powerful, heaviest). My lean: **`django-cotton`** —
its `<c-button variant="primary">…</c-button>` syntax parallels React JSX best,
so the parity contract is more obvious.
### What changes in the workflow
Before:
```
claude.ai atelier ──► whynot-design ──► consumer
```
After:
```
claude.ai atelier ──► whynot-design ──┬─► whynot-design-django ──► vergabe-teilnahme (+ future Django apps)
├─► future stacks: whynot-design-jinja / -svelte / -vue / …
└─► tokens flow into all child repos via a sync script
```
Concretely, this adds three new ongoing obligations:
1. **Token sync gate.** When whynot-design ships a token change, the Django repo's
sync script must run before its next release. CI check: the static CSS in
`whynot-design-django` must hash-match the CSS at the pinned upstream tag.
2. **Component parity gate.** When whynot-design adds or modifies a component, an
issue is opened automatically in `whynot-design-django` referencing the upstream
PR. A release is blocked until the issue closes. Encode in `CONTRIBUTING.md`
first; later, a CI cross-repo check.
3. **Conformance tests.** Each component's Django partial has a Playwright snapshot
that's compared against the same component rendered in whynot-design's
`examples/whynot-control/`. Drift = failing build.
Vergabe-teilnahme's workplan therefore depends on **whynot-design-django** existing
first. The vergabe workplan becomes: install the new package, replace partials with
cotton/include tags, retheme.
## 6. Component-level inventory — whynot-design vs. vergabe-teilnahme
| whynot-design (React) | vergabe-teilnahme (Django) | Match | Gap action |
|---|---|---|---|
| `Eyebrow` (mono uppercase label, fg-3) | — | Missing | New partial `atoms/eyebrow.html` |
| `Tag` (mono uppercase pill: default / active / draft) | `status_badge.html` (different semantics — domain statuses) | Partial | Replace `status_badge` content with `Tag` variants; keep status→variant mapping |
| `Button` (3 variants: primary / secondary / ghost; lucide icon support) | CSS classes `.btn-primary`, `.btn-secondary`, `.btn-danger`, `.btn-ghost` | Strong overlap; `btn-danger` not upstream | Adopt 3 base variants; propose `danger` upstream OR retire it (whynot's voice avoids red/destructive emphasis) |
| `StageDot` (S0S4 signal levels with grey-ramp + yellow S4) | `phase_nav.html` (numbered phase circles: todo/active/done/warn) | Semantically different — *whynot stages* ≠ *vergabe phases* | Keep both as distinct atoms. Propose `PhaseDot` upstream OR keep vergabe-local |
| `Stamp` (yellow rotated "DRAFT") | — | Missing | New partial; useful for unfreigegeben items |
| `Icon` (lucide via `data-lucide`) | inline SVGs / class-based | Missing as a component | New partial that wraps lucide; pull lucide JS into base.html |
| `TopNav` | `topbar.html` | Both exist; styling and density differ significantly | Reskin vergabe's topbar to whynot's structure (search box + primary action right-aligned) |
| `Sidebar` | `sidebar.html` | Both exist; nav model differs (vergabe has phase grouping; whynot has Work / Control docs grouping) | Adopt whynot's chrome (item style, eyebrow section headers) but keep vergabe's nav items |
| `PageHeader` (eyebrow + h1 + lede + actions) | — (inline per template) | Missing | New partial; refactor all page templates to use it |
| `PipelineStrip` (5-stage horizontal indicator) | `phase_nav.html` (vertical / different) | Semantically related, visually different | Decide: align on whynot's strip OR propose `PipelineStrip` variant upstream |
| — | `field_row.html` (vergabe-specific) | n/a | Propose upstream — it's a generic key/value display row |
| — | `breadcrumb.html` | n/a | Propose upstream as `Breadcrumb` |
| — | `feedback_button.html`, `feedback_modal.html`, `feedback_success.html` | n/a (vergabe-specific UX flow) | Keep vergabe-local; product UI, not DS atoms |
| — | `freigabe_modal.html`, `freigabe_success.html` | n/a (vergabe-specific) | Keep vergabe-local |
| — | `search_results.html` (HTMX results target) | n/a | Probably vergabe-local, but a `Listbox`/`Combobox` atom could live upstream — defer |
### Gap summary
- **5 net-new atoms** in vergabe (Eyebrow, Stamp, PageHeader, Icon wrapper, PipelineStrip).
- **4 atoms to align** (Tag ↔ status_badge, Button variants, TopNav, Sidebar).
- **2 atoms to propose upstream** (Breadcrumb, FieldRow).
- **1 semantic mismatch to resolve** (Stage vs Phase — they're different concepts).
- **All vergabe-specific flow UI** (feedback, freigabe, search_results) stays
vergabe-local — that's correct, those are product UI, not design system.
### Components missing from whynot-design — full gap list
These are components that are absent from `whynot-design` today and would need to
land there (or in `whynot-design-django`) before vergabe-teilnahme can fully adopt
the system. Grouped by origin.
#### Already exists in vergabe-teilnahme — candidates to promote upstream
1. **`Breadcrumb`** — vergabe's `breadcrumb.html`. Trivially generic; no
vergabe-specific semantics.
2. **`FieldRow`** — vergabe's `field_row.html` (label + value, 3-column grid). The
pattern recurs across detail pages; clearly a DS atom.
3. **`PhaseDot` / `PhaseNav`** *(name TBD)* — vergabe's `phase_nav.html`.
Semantically distinct from whynot's `StageDot` (numbered phases with
todo / active / done / warn states, not S0S4 signal levels). Either upstream
as a sibling component, or kept vergabe-local. **Open decision.**
#### Doesn't exist anywhere yet, but the DS clearly needs them
These are components that vergabe-teilnahme has as raw Tailwind classes or ad-hoc
markup, and whynot-design has no equivalent — but any non-trivial app needs them,
so they're real DS gaps:
4. **`Card`** — whynot's house rules reference cards ("no shadows on cards,"
"04px radii for cards/sheets") but there is no `Card` JSX component. Vergabe
has `.card` as a Tailwind class. **Surprising omission given the explicit
design rules.**
5. **`Input` / `Textarea` / `Select`** — whynot ships no form primitives at all.
Vergabe has `.form-input` and `.form-label` CSS classes. Required before any
form-based whynot artefact ships.
6. **`Modal` / `Dialog`** — whynot ships none. Vergabe has two (`freigabe_modal`,
`feedback_modal`). Whynot's house rules even prescribe modal radius (8px),
confirming the intent — just the component is missing.
7. **`Table`** — whynot ships none. Vergabe has `.table-base`, `.table-header`,
`.table-row` classes. Any data-heavy view (likely most of vergabe) needs it.
8. **`Toast` / inline success banner** *(name TBD)* — whynot ships none. Vergabe
has `freigabe_success.html` and `feedback_success.html` as ad-hoc partials.
Even with whynot's quiet voice, success / error states need a defined visual.
#### Worth flagging but defer until first real need
9. **`SearchInput`** — currently inlined inside whynot's `TopNav`. Pulling it out
as a standalone atom would be useful (vergabe's `search_results.html` is a
target for an HTMX-driven search box).
10. **`EmptyState`** — neither codebase has one; vergabe will need it for empty
list views. Worth designing once before either side fills the gap locally.
11. **`Tabs`, `Dropdown`, `Tooltip`, `Pagination`, `Avatar`** — common DS atoms;
neither side has them. Don't add speculatively; add when the first concrete
use case appears.
**Count:** 3 vergabe-existing to promote, 5 genuine DS-level gaps, 5 deferred.
The 5 "genuine DS-level gaps" — especially `Card`, `Input`, `Modal`, `Table` — are
**blockers for adoption**: vergabe can't replace its current chrome without them
existing somewhere shared.
### Stylistic gaps to address before "done"
- Vergabe currently uses Tailwind utility classes pervasively
(`.btn-primary { @apply … }`); whynot uses inline-style CSS-variable assignment.
The Django port should commit to one — recommend CSS variable + utility classes
(re-derive whynot's component styles as Tailwind `@apply` blocks that read from
CSS vars), so HTMX-injected fragments don't need their own style scaffolding.
- Lucide icons aren't wired into vergabe. Need a base.html script tag + an icon partial.
- Font stack mismatch: vergabe is `ui-sans-serif`; whynot is IBM Plex Sans / Mono /
Serif. Importing whynot's CSS handles this — but it pulls Google Fonts at runtime.
Decide self-host vs. CDN.
- Vergabe's brand blue (`#3b5bdb`) has to go entirely. No mid-state — the whynot
aesthetic forbids it.
## 7. Recommendation and open decision
**Recommendation:** Strategy B (parallel `whynot-design-django` repo) as the
immediate move, with the README explicitly framing it as a **bridge** that becomes
obsolete if whynot-design eventually pivots to Lit web components. Concretely this
means **three workplans**, not one:
1. **`whynot-design`**: small additions — tag v0.1.0, add upstream candidates
(`Breadcrumb`, `FieldRow`), document the parity contract for downstream Django port.
2. **`whynot-design-django`** (new repo): bootstrap, ship v0.1.0 with the 11
components + 2 vergabe-contributed atoms, set up token-sync + parity tests.
3. **`vergabe-teilnahme`** (`WP-0017`): consume `whynot-design-django`, retheme,
pilot on one page first, then full sweep.
**Open decision (blocks workplan drafting):**
Strategy A (pivot to Lit immediately) vs. Strategy B (parallel Django repo) vs.
"B now, A later" — Bernd to choose. If "B now, A later," add a workplan stub for
the Lit pivot in `whynot-design` itself so it doesn't get forgotten. If "A from the
start," the Django repo doesn't exist and the workplans collapse to two.
## Sources
- [Shoelace / Web Awesome](https://shoelace.style/) — framework-agnostic web components DS
- [Lit + Web Components for cross-framework UIs](https://thenewstack.io/how-to-build-framework-agnostic-uis-with-web-components/)
- [HTMX + Shoelace example](https://binaryigor.com/htmx-with-shoelace-framework-agnostic-components-in-an-example-app.html)
- [W3C Design Tokens spec first stable version (Oct 2025)](https://www.w3.org/community/design-tokens/2025/10/28/design-tokens-specification-reaches-first-stable-version/)
- [Style Dictionary cross-platform tokens](https://styledictionary.com/info/tokens/)
- [Django Cotton — HTML-like component syntax](https://django-cotton.com/)
- [django-bird](https://github.com/joshuadavidthomas/django-bird)
- [Salesforce — Beyond Components: multi-framework DS](https://medium.com/salesforce-ux/beyond-components-a-design-system-to-support-multiple-frameworks-cb1e4d511f66)
- [AgnosticUI post-mortem (rewrite to Lit)](https://frontendmasters.com/blog/post-mortem-rewriting-agnosticui-with-lit-web-components/)

39
scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh Executable file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
#!/usr/bin/env bash
# Synchronises the vendored copy of the whynot-design system from a pinned
# upstream commit. Source: ~/whynot-design (worktree) or a clone from gitea.
#
# Usage: ./scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh [<commit-or-ref>]
# Default: reads .whynot-design-ref from the vendor directory.
#
# See workplans/WP-0017-whynot-design-tokens.md for the adoption strategy.
set -euo pipefail
ROOT="$(cd "$(dirname "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")/.." && pwd)"
VENDOR_DIR="$ROOT/static/src/vendor/whynot-design"
REF_FILE="$VENDOR_DIR/.whynot-design-ref"
SRC_REPO="${WHYNOT_DESIGN_SRC:-$HOME/whynot-design}"
REF="${1:-}"
if [[ -z "$REF" && -f "$REF_FILE" ]]; then
REF="$(cat "$REF_FILE")"
fi
if [[ -z "$REF" ]]; then
echo "Usage: $0 <commit-or-ref> (or write a ref to $REF_FILE)" >&2
exit 2
fi
if [[ ! -d "$SRC_REPO/.git" ]]; then
echo "Source not found: $SRC_REPO" >&2
echo "Set WHYNOT_DESIGN_SRC or clone gitea:whynot/whynot-design there." >&2
exit 1
fi
mkdir -p "$VENDOR_DIR/tokens"
git -C "$SRC_REPO" show "$REF:src/styles/colors_and_type.css" \
> "$VENDOR_DIR/colors_and_type.css"
for f in colors.json type.json spacing.json index.json; do
git -C "$SRC_REPO" show "$REF:tokens/$f" > "$VENDOR_DIR/tokens/$f"
done
git -C "$SRC_REPO" rev-parse "$REF" > "$REF_FILE"
echo "Vendor synced → $VENDOR_DIR (ref: $(cat "$REF_FILE"))"

View File

@@ -1,3 +1,9 @@
/* whynot-design tokens & semantic element styles (pinned via
scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh; see .whynot-design-ref).
Must precede the Tailwind import so the @import url(...) for IBM Plex
ends up at the top of the generated bundle. */
@import "./vendor/whynot-design/colors_and_type.css";
@import "tailwindcss";
/* Explicit content sources. Without these, Tailwind's automatic detection
@@ -7,44 +13,88 @@
template dirs copied in the Dockerfile `assets` stage. */
@source "../../vergabe_teilnahme/templates";
/* whynot tokens → Tailwind theme. Exposes utilities like bg-paper, text-ink,
border-line, bg-paper-2, text-ink-3, … */
@theme {
--color-brand-50: #f0f4ff;
--color-brand-100: #dce7ff;
--color-brand-500: #3b5bdb;
--color-brand-600: #2f4ac7;
--color-brand-700: #2541b2;
--color-brand-900: #152d99;
--color-ink: #0A0A0A;
--color-ink-2: #1F1F1F;
--color-ink-3: #5C5C5C;
--color-ink-4: #8A8A8A;
--color-ink-5: #B5B5B3;
--color-line: #E5E5E2;
--color-line-strong: #C9C9C5;
--color-line-soft: #F0F0EC;
--color-paper: #FFFFFF;
--color-paper-2: #FAFAF7;
--color-paper-3: #F4F4EF;
--color-hi: #FFE14A;
--color-hi-2: #FFD400;
--color-hi-ink: #1A1500;
/* Backwards-compat aliases for legacy `brand-*` utility usage in templates.
Keeps Phase 1 a tokens-only swap; templates can migrate to ink/paper at
leisure. Map blue-brand scale onto the whynot ink ramp. */
--color-brand-50: #FAFAF7;
--color-brand-100: #F4F4EF;
--color-brand-500: #0A0A0A;
--color-brand-600: #1F1F1F;
--color-brand-700: #0A0A0A;
--color-brand-900: #0A0A0A;
}
/* Off-spec — vergabe-local until whynot-design defines a canonical
destructive color. See history/2026-05-23-whynot-design-cross-framework-analysis.md
§4 for context. */
:root {
--danger: #B22222;
--danger-fg: #FFFFFF;
}
@layer base {
/* German-app base resets */
html {
font-family: ui-sans-serif, system-ui, sans-serif;
font-family: var(--ff-sans, ui-sans-serif), system-ui, sans-serif;
}
}
@layer components {
.card { @apply bg-white rounded-xl border border-slate-200 shadow-sm p-6; }
.btn-primary { @apply bg-brand-500 text-white px-4 py-2 rounded-lg hover:bg-brand-600 transition-colors; }
.btn-secondary { @apply bg-white text-slate-700 border border-slate-300 px-4 py-2 rounded-lg hover:bg-slate-50; }
.btn-danger { @apply bg-red-600 text-white px-4 py-2 rounded-lg hover:bg-red-700; }
.btn-ghost { @apply text-slate-600 px-3 py-2 rounded-lg hover:bg-slate-100; }
.field-row { @apply grid grid-cols-3 gap-4 py-3 border-b border-slate-100 last:border-0; }
.field-label { @apply text-sm font-medium text-slate-500 col-span-1; }
.field-value { @apply text-sm text-slate-900 col-span-2; }
.phase-badge { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold; }
.phase-todo { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-slate-200 text-slate-500; }
.phase-active { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-brand-500 text-white; }
.phase-done { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-green-500 text-white; }
.phase-warn { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-amber-400 text-amber-900; }
.section-title { @apply text-base font-semibold text-slate-900 mb-4; }
.page-title { @apply text-2xl font-bold text-slate-900; }
.form-input { @apply w-full rounded-lg border border-slate-300 px-3 py-2 text-sm focus:outline-none focus:ring-2 focus:ring-brand-500 focus:border-transparent; }
.form-label { @apply block text-sm font-medium text-slate-700 mb-1; }
.table-base { @apply w-full text-sm text-left; }
.table-header { @apply bg-slate-50 text-slate-500 font-medium text-xs uppercase tracking-wide; }
.table-row { @apply border-t border-slate-100 hover:bg-slate-50 transition-colors; }
.sidebar-link { @apply flex items-center px-3 py-2 rounded-lg text-sm text-slate-700 hover:bg-slate-100 transition-colors; }
.sidebar-link-active { @apply bg-brand-50 text-brand-700 font-medium; }
.sidebar-section-btn { @apply w-full flex items-center justify-between px-3 py-2 text-xs font-semibold text-slate-500 uppercase tracking-wide hover:text-slate-700; }
/* Cards / sheets — whynot: no shadow, hairline border */
.card { @apply bg-paper rounded border border-line p-6; }
/* Buttons — whynot: 3 variants + off-spec danger */
.btn-primary { @apply bg-ink text-paper px-4 py-2 rounded hover:bg-ink-2 transition-colors; }
.btn-secondary { @apply bg-paper text-ink border border-line px-4 py-2 rounded hover:bg-paper-2 transition-colors; }
.btn-ghost { @apply text-ink-3 px-3 py-2 rounded hover:bg-paper-2; }
.btn-danger { background: var(--danger); color: var(--danger-fg); @apply px-4 py-2 rounded transition-colors; }
.btn-danger:hover { filter: brightness(0.92); }
/* Field-row — label/value grid */
.field-row { @apply grid grid-cols-3 gap-4 py-3 border-b border-line-soft last:border-0; }
.field-label { @apply text-sm font-medium text-ink-3 col-span-1; }
.field-value { @apply text-sm text-ink col-span-2; }
/* Phase indicators — vergabe semantics (todo/active/done/warn), translated
into whynot palette. `phase-warn` uses --hi (annotation yellow). */
.phase-badge { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold; }
.phase-todo { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-paper-3 text-ink-4; }
.phase-active { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-ink text-paper; }
.phase-done { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-ink-3 text-paper; }
.phase-warn { background: var(--hi); color: var(--hi-ink); @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold; }
/* Titles / sections */
.section-title { @apply text-base font-semibold text-ink mb-4; }
.page-title { @apply text-2xl font-medium text-ink tracking-tight; }
/* Forms */
.form-input { @apply w-full rounded border border-line px-3 py-2 text-sm bg-paper focus:outline-none focus:border-ink transition-colors; }
.form-label { @apply block text-sm font-medium text-ink-2 mb-1; }
/* Tables */
.table-base { @apply w-full text-sm text-left; }
.table-header { @apply bg-paper-2 text-ink-3 font-medium text-xs uppercase tracking-wide; }
.table-row { @apply border-t border-line-soft hover:bg-paper-2 transition-colors; }
/* Sidebar */
.sidebar-link { @apply flex items-center px-3 py-2 rounded text-sm text-ink-2 hover:bg-paper-2 transition-colors; }
.sidebar-link-active { @apply bg-paper text-ink font-medium; box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1px var(--line); }
.sidebar-section-btn { @apply w-full flex items-center justify-between px-3 py-2 text-xs font-semibold text-ink-4 uppercase tracking-wide hover:text-ink-2; }
}

View File

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
9419f166ce395858f55b10a5c72268a1fe9fc9d2

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,273 @@
/* ============================================================
WhyNot Design System — Colors & Type
------------------------------------------------------------
Neutral, mostly black/white. Color is used SPARINGLY — only
one warm accent (annotation yellow) borrowed from the LEGO
brick in the logo. The system favours light grey wireframe
artefacts over heavy fills.
============================================================ */
/* ---------- Webfonts (Google Fonts, see /fonts for offline) ---------- */
@import url("https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=IBM+Plex+Mono:wght@400;500;600&family=IBM+Plex+Sans:wght@300;400;500;600;700&family=IBM+Plex+Serif:ital,wght@0,400;0,500;1,400&display=swap");
:root {
/* ---------- Base palette: neutrals ---------- */
--ink: #0A0A0A; /* near-black, the only "fill" most of the time */
--ink-2: #1F1F1F;
--ink-3: #5C5C5C;
--ink-4: #8A8A8A;
--ink-5: #B5B5B3; /* placeholder text, wireframe labels */
--line: #E5E5E2; /* default 1px wireframe rule */
--line-strong: #C9C9C5; /* dividers between sections */
--line-soft: #F0F0EC; /* hairline within a card */
--paper: #FFFFFF; /* canvas */
--paper-2: #FAFAF7; /* sheet, dim canvas */
--paper-3: #F4F4EF; /* recessed surface, code block bg */
/* ---------- Foreground / background semantic ---------- */
--fg-1: var(--ink);
--fg-2: var(--ink-3);
--fg-3: var(--ink-4);
--fg-mute: var(--ink-5);
--fg-on-dark: #FAFAF7;
--bg-1: var(--paper);
--bg-2: var(--paper-2);
--bg-3: var(--paper-3);
--bg-invert: var(--ink);
--border: var(--line);
--border-strong: var(--line-strong);
--border-soft: var(--line-soft);
/* ---------- The single accent: annotation yellow ---------- */
/* Lifted from the LEGO brick. Used as highlighter, "draft"
stamp, signal-marker. Never as a button fill. */
--hi: #FFE14A;
--hi-2: #FFD400;
--hi-ink: #1A1500; /* text on yellow */
/* ---------- Status (for prototype lifecycle, signal strength) ---------- */
/* Kept deliberately desaturated so they read as labels, not UI. */
--status-raw: #B5B5B3; /* S0 — no signal */
--status-weak: #8A8A8A; /* S1 — weak signal */
--status-medium: #5C5C5C; /* S2 — medium signal */
--status-strong: #0A0A0A; /* S3 — strong signal */
--status-commercial: #FFD400; /* S4 — commercial */
/* ---------- Type families ---------- */
--ff-sans: "IBM Plex Sans", ui-sans-serif, system-ui, sans-serif;
--ff-mono: "IBM Plex Mono", ui-monospace, "SF Mono", Menlo, monospace;
--ff-serif: "IBM Plex Serif", "Iowan Old Style", Georgia, serif;
/* ---------- Type scale (modular, ~1.2) ---------- */
--fs-xs: 11px;
--fs-sm: 13px;
--fs-base: 15px;
--fs-md: 17px;
--fs-lg: 20px;
--fs-xl: 24px;
--fs-2xl: 32px;
--fs-3xl: 44px;
--fs-4xl: 64px;
--fs-5xl: 96px;
--lh-tight: 1.05;
--lh-snug: 1.25;
--lh-base: 1.5;
--lh-loose: 1.7;
--tr-tight: -0.02em;
--tr-snug: -0.01em;
--tr-base: 0em;
--tr-mono: 0.02em;
--tr-label: 0.08em; /* uppercase eyebrow labels */
/* ---------- Spacing (4px base) ---------- */
--sp-1: 4px;
--sp-2: 8px;
--sp-3: 12px;
--sp-4: 16px;
--sp-5: 24px;
--sp-6: 32px;
--sp-7: 48px;
--sp-8: 64px;
--sp-9: 96px;
--sp-10: 128px;
/* ---------- Radii — small, mostly square ---------- */
--r-0: 0px;
--r-1: 2px;
--r-2: 4px;
--r-3: 8px;
--r-pill: 999px;
/* ---------- Elevation — almost none. This is a wireframe system. ---------- */
--shadow-0: none;
--shadow-1: 0 1px 0 var(--line);
--shadow-2: 0 1px 0 var(--line-strong);
--shadow-3: 0 4px 12px -6px rgba(10,10,10,0.10);
}
/* ============================================================
Semantic element styles
============================================================ */
html {
font-family: var(--ff-sans);
font-size: var(--fs-base);
line-height: var(--lh-base);
color: var(--fg-1);
background: var(--bg-1);
-webkit-font-smoothing: antialiased;
-moz-osx-font-smoothing: grayscale;
text-rendering: optimizeLegibility;
}
body {
margin: 0;
font-feature-settings: "ss01", "cv11";
text-wrap: pretty;
}
/* ---------- Headings ---------- */
h1, .h1 {
font: 600 var(--fs-3xl)/var(--lh-tight) var(--ff-sans);
letter-spacing: var(--tr-tight);
margin: 0 0 var(--sp-5);
color: var(--fg-1);
}
h2, .h2 {
font: 500 var(--fs-2xl)/var(--lh-snug) var(--ff-sans);
letter-spacing: var(--tr-snug);
margin: 0 0 var(--sp-4);
}
h3, .h3 {
font: 500 var(--fs-xl)/var(--lh-snug) var(--ff-sans);
letter-spacing: var(--tr-snug);
margin: 0 0 var(--sp-3);
}
h4, .h4 {
font: 500 var(--fs-lg)/var(--lh-snug) var(--ff-sans);
margin: 0 0 var(--sp-2);
}
h5, .h5 {
font: 500 var(--fs-md)/var(--lh-snug) var(--ff-sans);
margin: 0 0 var(--sp-2);
}
/* ---------- Display (for hero / title slides) ---------- */
.display-1 {
font: 300 var(--fs-5xl)/0.95 var(--ff-sans);
letter-spacing: -0.035em;
color: var(--fg-1);
}
.display-2 {
font: 400 var(--fs-4xl)/1.0 var(--ff-sans);
letter-spacing: var(--tr-tight);
}
/* ---------- Body ---------- */
p {
margin: 0 0 var(--sp-4);
line-height: var(--lh-base);
color: var(--fg-1);
}
.lead {
font-size: var(--fs-md);
line-height: 1.55;
color: var(--fg-2);
}
small, .small {
font-size: var(--fs-sm);
color: var(--fg-2);
}
/* ---------- Eyebrow / uppercase labels (very common in this system) ---------- */
.eyebrow,
.label {
font: 500 var(--fs-xs)/1.2 var(--ff-mono);
letter-spacing: var(--tr-label);
text-transform: uppercase;
color: var(--fg-3);
}
/* ---------- Code / mono ---------- */
code, kbd, samp, pre, .mono {
font-family: var(--ff-mono);
font-size: 0.92em;
letter-spacing: var(--tr-mono);
}
code {
background: var(--bg-3);
padding: 1px 6px;
border-radius: var(--r-1);
color: var(--ink-2);
}
pre {
background: var(--bg-3);
border: 1px solid var(--border);
padding: var(--sp-4);
overflow-x: auto;
border-radius: var(--r-2);
font-size: var(--fs-sm);
line-height: var(--lh-snug);
}
pre code { background: none; padding: 0; }
/* ---------- Editorial serif moments ---------- */
.serif { font-family: var(--ff-serif); }
.serif-quote {
font: 400 italic var(--fs-xl)/1.4 var(--ff-serif);
color: var(--fg-2);
}
/* ---------- Links ---------- */
a {
color: var(--fg-1);
text-decoration: underline;
text-decoration-color: var(--border-strong);
text-underline-offset: 3px;
text-decoration-thickness: 1px;
transition: text-decoration-color 120ms ease, color 120ms ease;
}
a:hover {
text-decoration-color: var(--fg-1);
}
/* ---------- HR ---------- */
hr {
border: 0;
border-top: 1px solid var(--border);
margin: var(--sp-5) 0;
}
/* ---------- Highlighter (the one place yellow appears in body copy) ---------- */
mark, .mark {
background: var(--hi);
color: var(--hi-ink);
padding: 0 2px;
}
/* ---------- Tables (used in templates) ---------- */
table {
width: 100%;
border-collapse: collapse;
font-size: var(--fs-sm);
}
th, td {
text-align: left;
padding: var(--sp-3) var(--sp-4);
border-bottom: 1px solid var(--border);
}
th {
font-weight: 500;
color: var(--fg-2);
font-family: var(--ff-mono);
font-size: var(--fs-xs);
letter-spacing: var(--tr-label);
text-transform: uppercase;
}
/* ---------- Selection ---------- */
::selection { background: var(--hi); color: var(--hi-ink); }

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
{
"$schema": "https://design-tokens.github.io/community-group/format/",
"ink": { "value": "#0A0A0A", "type": "color", "comment": "Near-black. The only fill most of the time." },
"ink-2": { "value": "#1F1F1F", "type": "color" },
"ink-3": { "value": "#5C5C5C", "type": "color" },
"ink-4": { "value": "#8A8A8A", "type": "color" },
"ink-5": { "value": "#B5B5B3", "type": "color", "comment": "Placeholder text, wireframe labels." },
"line": { "value": "#E5E5E2", "type": "color", "comment": "Default 1px wireframe rule." },
"line-strong": { "value": "#C9C9C5", "type": "color" },
"line-soft": { "value": "#F0F0EC", "type": "color" },
"paper": { "value": "#FFFFFF", "type": "color" },
"paper-2": { "value": "#FAFAF7", "type": "color" },
"paper-3": { "value": "#F4F4EF", "type": "color" },
"hi": { "value": "#FFE14A", "type": "color", "comment": "Annotation yellow. Highlighter only, never a button fill." },
"hi-2": { "value": "#FFD400", "type": "color" },
"hi-ink": { "value": "#1A1500", "type": "color", "comment": "Text on yellow." },
"status-raw": { "value": "#B5B5B3", "type": "color", "comment": "S0 — no signal" },
"status-weak": { "value": "#8A8A8A", "type": "color", "comment": "S1 — weak signal" },
"status-medium": { "value": "#5C5C5C", "type": "color", "comment": "S2 — medium signal" },
"status-strong": { "value": "#0A0A0A", "type": "color", "comment": "S3 — strong signal" },
"status-commercial": { "value": "#FFD400", "type": "color", "comment": "S4 — commercial" }
}

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
{
"comment": "Manifest pointing at the three token files. Source-of-truth for any future Style Dictionary build.",
"colors": "./colors.json",
"type": "./type.json",
"spacing": "./spacing.json"
}

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
{
"$schema": "https://design-tokens.github.io/community-group/format/",
"spacing": {
"1": { "value": "4px", "type": "dimension" },
"2": { "value": "8px", "type": "dimension" },
"3": { "value": "12px", "type": "dimension" },
"4": { "value": "16px", "type": "dimension" },
"5": { "value": "24px", "type": "dimension" },
"6": { "value": "32px", "type": "dimension" },
"7": { "value": "48px", "type": "dimension" },
"8": { "value": "64px", "type": "dimension" },
"9": { "value": "96px", "type": "dimension" },
"10": { "value": "128px", "type": "dimension" }
},
"radius": {
"0": { "value": "0px", "type": "dimension" },
"1": { "value": "2px", "type": "dimension" },
"2": { "value": "4px", "type": "dimension" },
"3": { "value": "8px", "type": "dimension" },
"pill": { "value": "999px", "type": "dimension" }
},
"shadow": {
"0": { "value": "none", "type": "shadow" },
"1": { "value": "0 1px 0 #E5E5E2", "type": "shadow" },
"2": { "value": "0 1px 0 #C9C9C5", "type": "shadow" },
"3": { "value": "0 4px 12px -6px rgba(10,10,10,0.10)", "type": "shadow", "comment": "Floating elements only." }
}
}

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
{
"$schema": "https://design-tokens.github.io/community-group/format/",
"family": {
"sans": { "value": "\"IBM Plex Sans\", ui-sans-serif, system-ui, sans-serif", "type": "fontFamily" },
"mono": { "value": "\"IBM Plex Mono\", ui-monospace, \"SF Mono\", Menlo, monospace", "type": "fontFamily" },
"serif": { "value": "\"IBM Plex Serif\", \"Iowan Old Style\", Georgia, serif", "type": "fontFamily" }
},
"size": {
"xs": { "value": "11px", "type": "dimension" },
"sm": { "value": "13px", "type": "dimension" },
"base": { "value": "15px", "type": "dimension" },
"md": { "value": "17px", "type": "dimension" },
"lg": { "value": "20px", "type": "dimension" },
"xl": { "value": "24px", "type": "dimension" },
"2xl": { "value": "32px", "type": "dimension" },
"3xl": { "value": "44px", "type": "dimension" },
"4xl": { "value": "64px", "type": "dimension" },
"5xl": { "value": "96px", "type": "dimension" }
},
"lineHeight": {
"tight": { "value": 1.05, "type": "number" },
"snug": { "value": 1.25, "type": "number" },
"base": { "value": 1.5, "type": "number" },
"loose": { "value": 1.7, "type": "number" }
},
"tracking": {
"tight": { "value": "-0.02em", "type": "dimension" },
"snug": { "value": "-0.01em", "type": "dimension" },
"base": { "value": "0em", "type": "dimension" },
"mono": { "value": "0.02em", "type": "dimension" },
"label": { "value": "0.08em", "type": "dimension", "comment": "Uppercase eyebrow labels." }
}
}

View File

@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@
<link rel="stylesheet" href="{% static 'dist/main.css' %}">
<script src="{% static 'vendor/alpinejs/alpine.min.js' %}" defer></script>
</head>
<body class="bg-slate-50 min-h-screen">
<body class="bg-paper-2 min-h-screen text-ink">
{% include "partials/topbar.html" %}
<div class="flex h-[calc(100vh-56px)]">

50
wiki/DesignSystem.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,50 @@
# Design System
vergabe-teilnahme nutzt das `whynot-design`-System (gitea
`whynot/whynot-design`) als visuelle Basis.
## Phase 1 — Tokens + CSS (aktiv, ab WP-0017)
- Vendored CSS unter `static/src/vendor/whynot-design/`.
- Sync via `make sync-whynot-design` (Skript: `scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh`).
- Gepinnter Commit steht in `static/src/vendor/whynot-design/.whynot-design-ref`.
- `static/src/main.css` importiert die Vendor-CSS und mappt die whynot-Tokens
in den Tailwind-`@theme`-Block: `bg-ink`, `bg-paper`, `text-ink-3`,
`border-line` usw. sind als Utility-Klassen verfügbar.
- Legacy `bg-brand-*` / `text-brand-*` Utilities sind weiterhin nutzbar; sie
sind als Aliasse auf die ink/paper-Skala gemappt, damit Page-Templates
nicht in einer großen Migration mitgezogen werden müssen.
## Phase 2 — Komponenten (offen)
Adoption der whynot-Komponenten erfolgt sobald upstream Lit Web Components
und die fehlenden Atome (`Card`, `Modal`, `Input`, `Table`, `Toast`)
ausliefert. Eigener Workplan wird zu diesem Zeitpunkt angelegt.
## Lokale Abweichungen vom whynot-System
Dokumentiert direkt in `static/src/main.css`:
- **`.btn-danger`** nutzt ein Off-Spec-Rot (`#B22222`, `--danger`-Variable).
whynot definiert aktuell keine destruktive Farbe; vergabe-Nutzung erfordert
sie für Löschen-Aktionen. Wird zurückgebaut, sobald upstream eine
kanonische Lösung definiert.
## Visuelle Hausregeln aus whynot übernommen
- Mostly Black & White; gelber Akzent (`--hi: #FFE14A`) nur als Highlighter /
Stamp / S4-Signal — nie als Button-Fill oder Hero-Hintergrund.
- 1px-Hairlines (`var(--line)` / `border-line`), großzügiger Weißraum,
Monospace-Eyebrow-Labels.
- Keine Schatten auf Cards; nur Popovers bekommen einen weichen 412px-Shadow.
- 04px Border-Radius für Cards/Sheets; 8px nur für große Modale; Pill nur
für Tag-Capsules.
- IBM Plex Sans / Mono / Serif via Google-Fonts (`@import url(...)` in der
Vendor-CSS). Build-Container und Browser brauchen Internet-Zugriff zu
Google Fonts. Air-gapped Deployment würde self-hosting erfordern.
## Hintergrund
- Strategie-Analyse + Komponenten-Lücken-Inventar:
`history/2026-05-23-whynot-design-cross-framework-analysis.md`.
- Adoption-Workplan: `workplans/WP-0017-whynot-design-tokens.md`.

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,398 @@
---
id: WP-0017
title: whynot-design Adoption — Phase 1 (Tokens + CSS)
status: finished
phase: 17-of-n
created: "2026-05-23"
depends_on: WP-0016
---
# WP-0017 — whynot-design Adoption · Phase 1 (Tokens + CSS)
Übernahme des `whynot-design`-Systems
(`~/whynot-design`, gitea `whynot/whynot-design`) in vergabe-teilnahme in
**Phase 1: Tokens + CSS-Variablen**. Keine Komponenten-Portierung. Bestehende
Django-Partials und Tailwind-Komponentenklassen bleiben markup-seitig unverändert
und werden durch den CSS-Variablen-Tausch automatisch retoniert.
**Strategiebeschluss vom 2026-05-23:** zweistufige Adoption.
- Phase 1 (dieser Workplan): nur Tokens + CSS. whynot-spezifische Komponenten
(Lit Web Components) sind upstream in Arbeit und werden separat adoptiert.
- Phase 2 (eigener Workplan, kommt später): Komponenten-Adoption sobald
whynot-design die fehlenden Atome (`Card`, `Modal`, `Input`, `Table`, `Toast`)
als Lit Web Components ausliefert.
**Hintergrund:** ausführliche Analyse der Strategie-Optionen, Komponenten-
Inventar und Lücken-Liste in
`history/2026-05-23-whynot-design-cross-framework-analysis.md`.
**Designentscheidungen für Phase 1:**
- Distribution: **Vendoring** über Sync-Skript (kein npm/gitea SSH im Docker-Build).
- Rollout: **Big-Bang** — eine PR ersetzt die komplette `brand-*`-Palette
vergabe-weit. Markup-Änderungen sind nicht erforderlich.
- `btn-danger`: **Off-Spec-Rot** behalten (lokale `--danger`-Variable), bis
whynot-design eine kanonische Lösung definiert.
**Pinned upstream:** commit `9419f166ce395858f55b10a5c72268a1fe9fc9d2`
(Stand 2026-05-23; einziger Commit im whynot-design-Repo).
---
```task
id: WP-0017-T01
title: Vendor-Sync-Skript + initiale Vendor-Übernahme
status: done
Ziel: deterministisches Pull der whynot-design CSS-/Token-Quellen aus einem
gepinnten Commit nach `static/src/vendor/whynot-design/`, ohne Docker-Build
SSH-Zugang zu gitea zu geben.
**`scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh`** — neu anlegen:
```bash
#!/usr/bin/env bash
# Synchronisiert die Vendor-Kopie des whynot-Design-Systems aus einem gepinnten
# Upstream-Commit. Quelle: ~/whynot-design (Worktree) oder Klone aus gitea.
#
# Aufruf: ./scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh [<commit-or-ref>]
# Default: liest .whynot-design-ref aus dem Vendor-Verzeichnis.
set -euo pipefail
ROOT="$(cd "$(dirname "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")/.." && pwd)"
VENDOR_DIR="$ROOT/static/src/vendor/whynot-design"
REF_FILE="$VENDOR_DIR/.whynot-design-ref"
SRC_REPO="${WHYNOT_DESIGN_SRC:-$HOME/whynot-design}"
REF="${1:-}"
if [[ -z "$REF" && -f "$REF_FILE" ]]; then
REF="$(cat "$REF_FILE")"
fi
if [[ -z "$REF" ]]; then
echo "Usage: $0 <commit-or-ref> (or write a ref to $REF_FILE)" >&2
exit 2
fi
if [[ ! -d "$SRC_REPO/.git" ]]; then
echo "Quelle nicht gefunden: $SRC_REPO" >&2
echo "Setze WHYNOT_DESIGN_SRC oder klone gitea:whynot/whynot-design dorthin." >&2
exit 1
fi
mkdir -p "$VENDOR_DIR/tokens"
git -C "$SRC_REPO" show "$REF:src/styles/colors_and_type.css" \
> "$VENDOR_DIR/colors_and_type.css"
for f in colors.json type.json spacing.json index.json; do
git -C "$SRC_REPO" show "$REF:tokens/$f" > "$VENDOR_DIR/tokens/$f"
done
git -C "$SRC_REPO" rev-parse "$REF" > "$REF_FILE"
echo "Vendor synced → $VENDOR_DIR (ref: $(cat "$REF_FILE"))"
```
Ausführbar machen + initial syncen:
```bash
chmod +x scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh
./scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh 9419f166ce395858f55b10a5c72268a1fe9fc9d2
```
Erwartetes Resultat: `static/src/vendor/whynot-design/colors_and_type.css`,
`tokens/*.json`, `.whynot-design-ref` mit dem Commit-Hash.
**`Makefile`** — Target ergänzen:
```make
.PHONY: sync-whynot-design
sync-whynot-design:
./scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh
```
Commit-Hygiene: der Vendor-Inhalt wird **eingecheckt** (kein `.gitignore`).
Diffs gegen den Vendor sind Teil des Review-Surfaces beim nächsten Bump.
```
```task
id: WP-0017-T02
title: CSS-Integration in static/src/main.css
status: done
Ziel: whynot-Tokens werden global verfügbar, Tailwind-`@theme`-Mapping
exponiert sie als Utility-Klassen, vergabe-spezifisches Brand-Blau entfällt.
**`static/src/main.css`** — vollständig ersetzen (Reihenfolge ist wichtig:
whynot-CSS vor Tailwind, damit `@import url(...)` für IBM Plex am Anfang der
generierten Datei landet):
```css
/* whynot-design Tokens & semantische Element-Styles (gepinnt via
scripts/sync-whynot-design.sh; siehe .whynot-design-ref). */
@import "./vendor/whynot-design/colors_and_type.css";
@import "tailwindcss";
/* Tailwind v4 scannt diese Pfade für Utility-Klassen. Muss synchron mit
der Dockerfile `assets`-Stage bleiben. */
@source "../../vergabe_teilnahme/templates";
/* whynot-Tokens → Tailwind-Theme.
Erlaubt: bg-paper, text-ink, border-line, bg-paper-2, text-ink-3, … */
@theme {
--color-ink: var(--ink);
--color-ink-2: var(--ink-2);
--color-ink-3: var(--ink-3);
--color-ink-4: var(--ink-4);
--color-ink-5: var(--ink-5);
--color-line: var(--line);
--color-line-strong: var(--line-strong);
--color-line-soft: var(--line-soft);
--color-paper: var(--paper);
--color-paper-2: var(--paper-2);
--color-paper-3: var(--paper-3);
--color-hi: var(--hi);
--color-hi-2: var(--hi-2);
--color-hi-ink: var(--hi-ink);
}
/* Off-Spec — vergabe-lokal, bis whynot-design eine kanonische destruktive
Farbe definiert. Siehe history/2026-05-23-whynot-design-cross-framework-analysis.md
§4 "btn-danger". */
:root {
--danger: #B22222;
--danger-fg: #FFFFFF;
}
@layer base {
html {
font-family: var(--ff-sans, ui-sans-serif), system-ui, sans-serif;
}
}
@layer components {
/* Karten / Sheets — whynot: ohne Shadow, hairline border */
.card { @apply bg-paper rounded border border-line p-6; }
/* Buttons — whynot: 3 Varianten + off-spec danger */
.btn-primary { @apply bg-ink text-paper px-4 py-2 rounded hover:bg-ink-2 transition-colors; }
.btn-secondary { @apply bg-paper text-ink border border-line px-4 py-2 rounded hover:bg-paper-2 transition-colors; }
.btn-ghost { @apply text-ink-3 px-3 py-2 rounded hover:bg-paper-2; }
.btn-danger { background: var(--danger); color: var(--danger-fg); @apply px-4 py-2 rounded transition-colors; }
.btn-danger:hover { filter: brightness(0.92); }
/* Field-Row — Label/Value Grid */
.field-row { @apply grid grid-cols-3 gap-4 py-3 border-b border-line-soft last:border-0; }
.field-label { @apply text-sm font-medium text-ink-3 col-span-1; }
.field-value { @apply text-sm text-ink col-span-2; }
/* Phasen-Indikatoren — vergabe-Semantik (todo/active/done/warn), in
whynot-Palette übersetzt. `phase-warn` nutzt `--hi` (annotation yellow). */
.phase-badge { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold; }
.phase-todo { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-paper-3 text-ink-4; }
.phase-active { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-ink text-paper; }
.phase-done { @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold bg-ink-3 text-paper; }
.phase-warn { background: var(--hi); color: var(--hi-ink); @apply inline-flex items-center justify-center w-7 h-7 rounded-full text-sm font-bold; }
/* Titel / Sektionen */
.section-title { @apply text-base font-semibold text-ink mb-4; }
.page-title { @apply text-2xl font-medium text-ink tracking-tight; }
/* Formulare */
.form-input { @apply w-full rounded border border-line px-3 py-2 text-sm bg-paper focus:outline-none focus:border-ink transition-colors; }
.form-label { @apply block text-sm font-medium text-ink-2 mb-1; }
/* Tabellen */
.table-base { @apply w-full text-sm text-left; }
.table-header { @apply bg-paper-2 text-ink-3 font-medium text-xs uppercase tracking-wide; }
.table-row { @apply border-t border-line-soft hover:bg-paper-2 transition-colors; }
/* Sidebar */
.sidebar-link { @apply flex items-center px-3 py-2 rounded text-sm text-ink-2 hover:bg-paper-2 transition-colors; }
.sidebar-link-active { @apply bg-paper text-ink font-medium; box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1px var(--line); }
.sidebar-section-btn { @apply w-full flex items-center justify-between px-3 py-2 text-xs font-semibold text-ink-4 uppercase tracking-wide hover:text-ink-2; }
}
```
**Kommentar zu Border-Radii:** whynot-Hausregel verlangt 04px für Cards/Sheets,
8px nur für große Modale. Tailwind `rounded` (= 4px) erfüllt das. Keine
`rounded-xl`/`rounded-lg` mehr in den Komponenten-Klassen.
**Kommentar zu Shadows:** whynot-Regel "no shadows on cards". `shadow-sm` wurde
aus `.card` entfernt; Sidebar-Active nutzt `inset` border statt Schatten.
**Kommentar zu Fonts:** `colors_and_type.css` zieht IBM Plex via
`@import url("https://fonts.googleapis.com/...")`. Build-Container und Browser
brauchen Internet-Zugriff zu Google Fonts. Für air-gapped Deployment muss das
später durch self-hosting ersetzt werden — ist heute nicht relevant
(coulombcore k3s hat Internet-Egress).
```
```task
id: WP-0017-T03
title: Base-Template — Body-Hintergrund auf whynot-Palette
status: done
**`vergabe_teilnahme/templates/base.html`** — Body-Klasse anpassen:
```diff
- <body class="bg-slate-50 min-h-screen">
+ <body class="bg-paper-2 min-h-screen text-ink">
```
Damit der Default-Text vom whynot-Ink-Ton kommt und der Canvas auf Sheet-Beige
(`#FAFAF7`) liegt, nicht auf Slate-Blau-50.
Keine weiteren Markup-Änderungen in Phase 1. Alle `bg-slate-*`/`text-slate-*`
Utilities in den Page-Templates werden in T05 (Smoke-Test) gesichtet und nur
dann gepatcht, wenn sie visuell brechen — Tailwinds Slate-Skala existiert
weiterhin parallel zur whynot-Palette.
```
```task
id: WP-0017-T04
title: Build + Static-Asset-Prüfung
status: done
Lokaler Build:
```bash
npm ci
npm run build
ls -lh static/dist/main.css
```
Erwartet: `main.css` enthält die whynot-CSS-Variablen am Anfang, gefolgt von
generierten Tailwind-Utilities. Größe steigt moderat (whynot-CSS ≈ 8 KB
unkompressed).
**Sanity-Check** der generierten Utilities:
```bash
grep -c "bg-ink\|bg-paper\|text-ink\|border-line" static/dist/main.css
# Erwartet: > 0 (Beweis, dass @theme-Mapping aktiv ist)
grep -c "color-brand-500\|3b5bdb" static/dist/main.css
# Erwartet: 0 (Alt-Palette komplett raus)
```
Falls eine vergabe-Template-Datei noch `bg-brand-*` o.ä. nutzt: in T05
adressieren (visueller Bruch wird dort sichtbar).
```
```task
id: WP-0017-T05
title: Big-Bang Smoke-Test — visueller Durchlauf aller Hauptseiten
status: done
Dev-Server starten und durch die wichtigsten Views klicken. Bei jedem visuellen
Bruch (Kontrast, weiße Schrift auf weißem Grund, harte Farb-Fremdkörper) eine
kurze Notiz machen und im selben Task patchen.
```bash
docker-compose -f docker-compose.dev.yml up -d
# oder: uv run python manage.py runserver
```
Zu prüfende Views (Mindestliste — Anordnung folgt der Sidebar):
- [ ] Dashboard / Ausschreibungs-Übersicht
- [ ] Ausschreibung Detail (Phasen-Nav sichtbar)
- [ ] Lose-Liste + Detail
- [ ] Aufgaben-Liste
- [ ] Dokumente-Übersicht
- [ ] Preise-Auswertung
- [ ] Partner-Bibliothek
- [ ] Marktbegleiter
- [ ] Nachbetrachtung
- [ ] Feedback-Modal (Trigger via Bug-Button)
- [ ] Freigabe-Modal (auf einem freigabefähigen Objekt)
- [ ] Search-Results (HTMX-Suche in der Top-Bar)
**Typische Brüche, die zu erwarten sind:**
1. Direkt im Template inline gesetzte `bg-blue-*`, `text-blue-*`, `bg-brand-*`
in den whynot-Äquivalenten ersetzen (`bg-ink`, `text-ink`, `bg-hi`).
2. `shadow-sm`/`shadow-md` auf Cards — entfernen (whynot-Regel: keine Shadows
auf Cards, nur auf Popovers).
3. `rounded-lg`/`rounded-xl` auf nicht-Modal-Elementen — auf `rounded` (=4px)
reduzieren.
4. Fokus-Ringe in Brand-Blau — der `.form-input`-Style nutzt jetzt Border-Ink;
Tailwind-Default-Ring kann noch blau sein, ggf. globalen Ring-Reset
ergänzen.
Screenshots der Hauptseiten **vor und nach** dem Swap in
`history/2026-05-23-whynot-design-phase1-screenshots/` ablegen, als
Sichtprüfungs-Beleg.
```
```task
id: WP-0017-T06
title: Doku-Update und Phase-2-Pflock
status: done
**`wiki/`** — neue Datei `wiki/DesignSystem.md` mit knappem Inhalt:
```markdown
# Design System
vergabe-teilnahme nutzt das `whynot-design`-System
(gitea `whynot/whynot-design`) als visuelle Basis.
**Phase 1 (aktuell, ab WP-0017):** nur Tokens + CSS-Variablen, vendoring nach
`static/src/vendor/whynot-design/`. Sync via `make sync-whynot-design`. Aktuell
gepinnter Commit: siehe `static/src/vendor/whynot-design/.whynot-design-ref`.
**Phase 2 (offen):** Komponenten-Adoption sobald upstream Lit Web Components
und die fehlenden Atome (Card, Modal, Input, Table, Toast) ausliefert. Eigener
Workplan wird zu diesem Zeitpunkt angelegt.
**Lokale Abweichungen** vom whynot-System (dokumentiert in `main.css`):
- `btn-danger` mit Off-Spec-Rot (`#B22222`) — whynot definiert keine
destruktive Farbe; vergabe-Nutzung erfordert sie für Löschen-Aktionen.
Wird zurückgebaut, sobald upstream eine kanonische Lösung definiert.
**Hintergrund:** Strategie-Analyse + Komponenten-Lücken in
`history/2026-05-23-whynot-design-cross-framework-analysis.md`.
```
**`CLAUDE.md` / `.claude/rules/stack-and-commands.md`** — Stack-Eintrag
ergänzen um `whynot-design` und den Sync-Befehl:
```markdown
## Stack
- **Language:** Python 3.12 (Django 6), Node 22 (Vite/Tailwind v4)
- **Key deps:** Django, htmx, Alpine.js, Tailwind v4, whynot-design (vendored)
## Dev Commands
# Design-System-Vendor aktualisieren (whynot-design Pin bumpen)
make sync-whynot-design
```
**Workplan-Index** in `workplans/README.md` ist bereits 12-Workplan-zentriert
und veraltet (es gibt jetzt 17). Nicht in diesem WP anpassen — eigener
Aufräum-WP, falls der Index wieder verbindlich werden soll.
```
---
## Nicht in diesem Workplan
- Komponenten-Portierung (React-JSX → Django-Partials) — entfällt; wird durch
upstream Lit Web Components in Phase 2 obsolet.
- `whynot-design-django`-Repo — entfällt aus dem gleichen Grund.
- Neue Atome (Card, Modal, Input, Table, Toast als DS-Komponenten) — kommen
upstream; bis dahin vergabe-lokal über Tailwind-Klassen.
- Visuelle Regression-Tests (Playwright) — wäre sinnvoll, aber nicht
Voraussetzung für Phase 1.
- Markup-Änderungen in Page-Templates über das in T05 Notwendige hinaus.
## Definition of Done
- `static/src/vendor/whynot-design/colors_and_type.css` vorhanden,
`.whynot-design-ref` enthält gepinnten Commit-Hash.
- `npm run build` erfolgreich, `static/dist/main.css` ohne `#3b5bdb`
(Alt-Brand-Blau) und mit aktiven `bg-ink`/`bg-paper`-Utilities.
- Alle 12 Smoke-Test-Views in T05 visuell durchgegangen, Brüche gepatcht,
Screenshots in `history/` abgelegt.
- `wiki/DesignSystem.md` existiert und referenziert History-Artefakt +
Phase-2-Bedingung.